I keep hearing AI experts say that electricians, plumbers, construction workers, gardeners, etc. will be some of the safest and best-paid jobs in an AI-driven future...is this real?

Reddit r/singularity News

Summary

A discussion questioning the common claim that trades like plumbing and electrical work will be the safest, best-paid jobs in an AI-driven economy, arguing that mass migration into these trades could drive wages down and that roles building, programming, and supervising AI may prove more valuable.

I keep hearing AI experts say that electricians, plumbers, construction workers, gardeners, etc. will be some of the safest and best-paid jobs in an AI-driven future. But isn't there a pretty obvious supply/demand problem here? If AI replaces a huge percentage of today's jobs, millions of people could move into these "AI-proof" trades. Today, maybe there aren't enough electricians. But if suddenly 10x more people want to become electricians because everyone says it's the safe career, wouldn't wages eventually fall? This makes me think the more valuable jobs might actually be above AI rather than outside it, people who build, program, manage and supervise AI and robots, especially in situations where humans still need to be accountable. We've already had an industrial revolution. Machines didn't just replace workers; they changed which skills were valuable. So are we making the same mistake by assuming that "AI can't physically do this job" automatically means "this job will be highly paid"? Curious what you guys think.
Original Article

Similar Articles

AI will also take the manual labor jobs, even before we invent robots

Reddit r/ArtificialInteligence

A social media post arguing that AI will displace blue-collar jobs too, since most skilled trades rely heavily on brain-work (diagnosis, decision-making) that superhuman AI can perform, leaving only the physical execution that untrained people could do with brief practice.

I Guess I Should Have Become a Plumber

Reddit r/AI_Agents

An opinion piece arguing that AI will not only replace software engineers but eventually all skilled trades, including plumbing, and that CS students should focus on problem-solving skills rather than fearing automation.