Anyone Else Think about Chomsky? Being Full of Shit

Reddit r/ArtificialInteligence News

Summary

The article contrasts Noam Chomsky's views on Universal Grammar with modern AI language models, highlighting how statistical learning in GPUs has achieved superior grammar and understanding.

Noam Chomsky. This guy. Guy who talked so good (and so much) he got his own -ism and -ists. Made a name for himself arguing that human language was the product of some inherent, Universal Grammar. Made a big point that language is a reflection of those rules, not statistical associations. Basically that language isn't learned. Some quotes: “Contrary to what people thought, language is not taught, not even learned.” 1992 — Interview with Naomi F. Chase, published by MIT, April 1. "It’s not doing it by statistical analysis, because the ape can do roughly the same probabilistic analysis.” 2012 — Interview with Yarden Katz, The Atlantic, November 1. Fast forward, it's now 2026. Your GPU can now talk to you. Its training data is just stuff on the internet + scanned books. It's training method is purely statistical. And it has better "grammar" than 99% of the population, along with an understanding of higher level maths good enough to move the field forward.
Original Article

Similar Articles

AI is the Ultimate Bullshitter

Reddit r/artificial

An opinion piece arguing that AI systems, especially large language models, are fundamentally bullshitters because they generate plausible but false information without understanding or intent to deceive.

Bullshit About Bullshit Machines [pdf]

Hacker News Top

A PDF essay critically examining AI language models (so-called 'bullshit machines'), likely arguing about their tendency to produce false or misleading outputs. The content appears to be a polemical or philosophical piece on the nature of AI-generated misinformation.