Yes, Astra is very capable, but...

Reddit r/singularity News

Summary

The author criticizes the AI model Astra for poor code architecture decisions and resistance to deleting unwanted code, arguing it should be better trained for long-term software engineering practices.

I've been having trouble with one of my projects and asked it to generate a tree so I can visualize the architecture. The result is hideous: the features are just designed without much thought to the overall architecture; there's overengineering everywhere; and most importantly: lots of duplicated code, and many small functions given a full module. Astra can backtrack, and even undo, a bad/incorrect assumption in the project. But it STILL tends to be averse to delete unwanted code, and it tries to keep bad/incorrect code "for compatibility." And it puzzles me why OpenAI doesn't train Astra to actually be good at engineering and making longer-term decisions. If you want to truly train a model to vibe code, it must commit to long-term architectural choices that will make the project last, and avoid it to collapse. And yes, a software engineer CAN prompt most models trained in the last 1-2 years to do cohese architectural choices. But as it stands, it's an uphill battle: they tend to resist giving a thought and respect those architectural decisions whenever they can (with newer models being better at that, naturally).
Original Article

Similar Articles

Astra for Coding: Why Are We Doing This Again?

Armin Ronacher

The article critiques the AI model GPT 6 Astra for generating poor-quality code in software engineering tasks despite its impressive capabilities, suggesting that AI training may reward task completion over output quality.

Okay Astra is insane.

Reddit r/openclaw

The user shares their experience where Astra quickly fixed bugs in a dashboard, outperforming Gemini 3.1 pro, and praises OpenAI's model capabilities.

Insider's opinion on Astra capabilities

Reddit r/singularity

An insider evaluates GPT Astra's capabilities, highlighting its strength in long-running tasks, orchestration, applying academic literature, and code generation, with noted improvements in creative writing over previous models.