This article offers a practical framework for evaluating AI agent tools by focusing on key questions about job clarity, access needs, autonomy, maintenance, cost, and exit options, moving beyond feature comparisons.
I know, another framework in an AI subreddit. (Yikes) My main aim behind writing this post is to move the conversation away from comparing features (they stopped helping me) and instead use a simpler set of questions. Also, each homepage now seems to promise the same things across memory, tool use and some version of autonomy. Here is how I would do it now: 1. What exact job am I giving it? I try to write this in one sentence and describe the job clearly. For eg., “Every morning, check the support inbox, draft replies and flag anything involving a refund.” This is much easier to evaluate instead of saying I need an agent for customer support. 2. What does it need access to? It could be a browser/ Local files/ Email/ a CRM/ Internal tools. This rules out a surprising number of options because you want to sign up the Agent for success and not have it hit permissions. 3. What can it do without asking me? This one I learnt the hard way. I had it send an ex boss a Slack message 6 months and I had to sit through the embarrassment of explaining that it was not me. Now, I give it a clear list of things that I trust it with and label them as "safe actions". Rest needs approvals. 5. How much babysitting does it need after the first week? I have had this happen on too many occasions that the first 2-3 runs were successful but it went downhill thereafter. Now I look at how often I have to repeat context, correct the same mistake, restart a workflow or check whether the task actually finished. 6. What does a completed task really cost? Since I am founder of a young startup, I need to be conscious about my resources including time. I include the subscription, model usage, retries and my own time fixing things. 7. Can I leave easily? Some tools can be notorious like that and add friction if you want to pull out. So now I ask if I can export the prompts, memory, workflows and logs. Agent tools are changing too quickly to build everything around something I cannot move away from. My current test is simple: give two tools the same real task for a week and track successful completions, corrections, failures, recovery time and total cost. What would you add to this?
Discusses whether AI agents should recommend tools based on users' current needs or consider future scalability, and how to communicate potential long-term limitations.