Project Shadows: Turns out "just add memory" doesn't fix your agent

Reddit r/artificial News

Summary

An analysis exploring limitations in AI agent design, arguing that simply increasing memory capacity is insufficient to address fundamental architectural issues in how agents are built and function.

Been building a multi-agent system called Shadows for a few months. Nine agents collaborating on strategy work with a shared memory layer. I spent most of my time on retrieval because that's what every benchmark measures. Mem0, MemPalace, Graphiti, all of them. On LongMemEval, recall_all@5 hit 97%. Overall accuracy was 73%. So the right memories are there. The agent still picks the wrong answer. It can't aggregate across sessions, doesn't know when to abstain, and guesses which aspect of a preference the user meant. That lined up with something I've been stuck on. Most LLMs jump straight to execution when you give them a task. People don't. We filter first, check if we're even the right person, then start. Next direction: Agents that can be moved with their identity and memory!
Original Article
View Cached Full Text

Cached at: 04/20/26, 08:56 AM

# Part 3: Project Shadows Source: https://omarmegawer.substack.com/p/part-3-project-shadows?r=4b5w1p&showWelcomeOnShare=true&triedRedirect=true Nothing too serious, but I tend to feel something is off with how we see and build things these days. This is me trying to make sense of it. By Omar Megawer · Launched 16 days ago By subscribing, you agree Substack's Terms of Use (https://substack.com/tos), and acknowledge its Information Collection Notice (https://substack.com/ccpa#personal-data-collected) and Privacy Policy (https://substack.com/privacy).

Similar Articles

Memory for agents ain't here yet

Reddit r/AI_Agents

A critique of current memory solutions for AI agents, arguing that RAG wrappers and similar approaches fail to address core issues of model bias and context bloat.

The Real Truth About AI Agents

Reddit r/AI_Agents

An experienced practitioner shares hard-won lessons from deploying 25+ AI agents to production, arguing that memory, orchestration, and auditability matter far more than model choice. The article details common failure modes like context loss and silent cost loops, and recommends a stack including Claude Sonnet 4, Pydantic AI, and dedicated memory layers like Octopodas.