Is MCP still relevant now that AI agents can just crawl the website/Swagger docs directly?

Reddit r/AI_Agents News

Summary

A discussion on whether the Model Context Protocol (MCP) remains relevant as AI agents increasingly crawl websites or Swagger/OpenAPI docs directly, comparing the reliability and advantages of each approach.

I've been thinking about this for a few weeks and wanted to get your take. MCP emerged as a way to standardize how AI accesses external tools/APIs. But with the latest generation of agents, I'm seeing more and more cases where the AI just crawls the website or Swagger/OpenAPI docs directly, and manages fine without going through a dedicated MCP server. So it makes me wonder: does MCP still hold a real advantage in this context (reliability, auth handling, token consumption, state between calls...), or are we seeing a "brute force" approach emerge, where the agent reads the docs on the fly and adapts, without needing a standardized contract? Personally, I've seen cases where crawling works great (well-documented REST APIs) and others where it clearly struggles (poorly documented APIs, need for state, complex permissions). But I wonder if MCP will remain an essential standard long-term, or if it's more of a transitional solution while agents get good enough to figure out any doc on their own. What do you think? Any concrete examples where one clearly outperformed the other?
Original Article

Similar Articles

@swyx: explain this

X AI KOLs Following

This article explains the Model Context Protocol (MCP) for building pluggable AI agent architectures, detailing lessons from building an MCP server at Sentry, including OAuth 2.1 integration, designing agent-friendly tool interfaces, and current ecosystem limitations.

Is MCP actually reducing integration work for agents?

Reddit r/AI_Agents

The article explores whether the Model Context Protocol (MCP) effectively reduces integration work for AI agents by standardizing agent-tool communication, comparing native MCP integration in Evose to manual wiring in other stacks like LangGraph and CrewAI.

@RhysSullivan: https://x.com/RhysSullivan/status/2070311929038680262

X AI KOLs Following

The author reflects on why the Model Context Protocol (MCP) has struggled, contrasting it with CLI-based agent workflows and arguing for more flexible tool integration. They suggest that agents should support MCP, CLI, API, etc., and express optimism about MCP's future despite current challenges.

MCP…. Is bad?

Reddit r/LocalLLaMA

The article critiques MCP (Model Context Protocol), arguing that it has significant flaws or is detrimental to AI development.