Pre-2022 Books

Hacker News Top News

Summary

A personal reflection on preferring pre-2022 books because they were written without AI assistance, questioning the value of human effort in the age of LLMs.

No content available
Original Article
View Cached Full Text

Cached at: 06/20/26, 11:18 PM

# Pre-2022 Books | Notes by Lorenzo Gravina Source: [https://notes.lorenzogravina.com/musings/pre-2022-books](https://notes.lorenzogravina.com/musings/pre-2022-books) I noticed that I seem to, subconsciously, gravitate towards books published on or before 2022, and somewhat discount books published after, especially from authors I haven’t heard of\. A part of me tells me I shouldn’t feel this\. I like and use LLMs often for coding work, and I know that they can create great results\. And after all, if the result is good, who cares about what tool was used to create it? When I read a pre\-2022 book, I know that each word was typed in manually, checked manually, edited manually, proofread manually\. That, somehow, has an effect on me, and leads me to give greater weight to the book and what’s said in it\. I don’t want to sound like those who “worried” about society being dumbed down by writing, printing, newspapers, radio, television, and then the Internet\. I’d just be yelling at the clouds\. But I can’t help but feel that the effort*meant*something\. I don’t know what the solution to this is, and there doesn’t have to be one\. Perhaps we’ll get used to this new tool, and move on\.

Similar Articles

LLMs and performative productivity

Lobsters Hottest

A developer reflects on using AI agents and questions whether the apparent productivity gains are genuine or merely performative, noting that while tasks are completed faster, deep understanding and real value may be lost.

Quoting Bryan Cantrill

Simon Willison's Blog

Bryan Cantrill critiques LLMs for lacking the optimization constraint of human laziness, arguing that LLMs will unnecessarily complicate systems rather than improve them, and highlighting how human time limitations drive the development of efficient abstractions.

Replies to comments on my "LLMs are eroding my career" post

Hacker News Top

The author replies to comments on their viral post about LLMs eroding their software engineering career, discussing how AI automation is reducing the need for deep domain knowledge in fintech and the challenges of maintaining diligence in a vibecoding culture.

Counterargument for Critical Thinking as Judged by AI and Humans

arXiv cs.CL

This study investigates the use of student-written counterarguments to AI-generated content to foster critical thinking in an educational context, and finds that frontier LLMs can evaluate such submissions with moderate agreement to human assessors.