Ai still sucks
Summary
作者讲述了使用 AI 研究工具分析电信与卫星频谱公告时,工具输出看似专业却充满错误的经历,强调不能把表达质量等同于研究质量,关键工作仍需人类专业判断把关。
Similar Articles
AI research tools are still too eager to turn public signals into certainty
The author critiques AI research tools for overconfidence in weak signals, praising Komo AI's rapid discovery and source-attached summaries but highlighting the need for better uncertainty and contradiction handling. They describe a workflow that splits discovery, verification, and structured checking across multiple AI tools.
“It’s just another tool”
作者针对会议上‘AI只是又一个工具’及‘AI没有判断力’等流行观点提出反驳,认为AI在写作、情绪稳定性和风险识别上已超越大多数人类,质疑行业资深人士对AI取代非AI工作者的低估。
@yanhua1010: I never had high expectations for domestic AI Agents, until this time it did something that surprised me. I asked Tencent WorkBuddy to do a competitive analysis, and it dispatched an entire research team, with one AI specifically for review. It sent back the report written by its colleagues because a number in it had no verifiable source...
A user shares their experience using Tencent WorkBuddy for competitive research. The AI deployed a research team, and a dedicated review AI caught a number without a source, rejected the report, and had it redone. The final output was a presentation-ready slide deck.
@feltanimalworld: Master, your post kept me pondering for two whole days! I originally wanted to write a long piece, but there were too many threads and I didn't know where to start. To sum it up, this is why I've been on Twitter lately—I felt something crucial was missing in my development understanding; it's also why, besides my hardware repair work, I've had to look into text-to-CAD recently. I...
The author discusses the lack of intermediate representation (IR) and verifier in the deployment of AI in serious industries, using text-to-CAD as an example to illustrate the key role of unified IR and verification in the feasibility of AI solutions.
@Etudecn: https://x.com/Etudecn/status/2073072648922481000
The article criticizes that most users are currently using AI inefficiently, points out that there are faster methods that are not widely known, and mentions AI tools such as Claude, GPT, and Mira.