Generating in the Limit with Infinitely Many Hallucinations

# Generating in the Limit with Infinitely Many Hallucinations
Source: [https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354)
###### Abstract

The classic paradigm of language identification in the limit models learning as a game between an adversary, who reveals strings from an unknown target language, and a learner tasked with identifying that language\. The recently introduced framework of language generation in the limit shifted the objective to better reflect modern language modeling, requiring the learner to produce valid, unseen strings from the target language\. Related work highlighted a fundamental tension: a broad coverage of the target often comes at the cost of validity\. We introduce a new notion of precision and recast this problem as the classic recall–precision trade\-off\. We analyze generation in the limit under varying constraints on enumeration, novelty, and validity, aimed at reflecting settings closer to those encountered by large language models\. A key contribution is our analysis of learners that are not eventually valid: we allow infinitely many mistakes, provided their frequency tends to zero so that precision remains one\. We show that this relaxation can strictly increase recall when the adversary permanently withholds a large portion of the target language\. We also study a continuous relaxation of the novelty constraint that requires only a fixed fraction of outputs to be novel\. Taken together, our results move toward a more realistic model of language generation where occasional errors and repetitions are unavoidable, but their rates are controlled\.

## 1Introduction

PartialFullPartialFullNoveltyπ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥α/2\\begin\{aligned\} \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}&=1\\\\\[\-1\.0pt\] \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}&\\geq\\alpha/2\\end\{aligned\}[Theorem˜3\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem5)Kleinberg and Wei\([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥1/2\\begin\{aligned\} \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}&=1\\\\\[\-1\.0pt\] \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}&\\geq 1/2\\end\{aligned\}[Theorem˜3\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem5)Kleinberg and Wei\([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥max\(1−β,α/3\)\\begin\{aligned\} \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}&=1\\\\\[\-1\.0pt\] \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}&\\geq\\hskip\-2\.0pt\\left\.\\begin\{smallmatrix\}\{\\scriptstyle\\max\(1\{\-\}\\beta,\}\\\\ \{\\scriptstyle\\alpha/3\)\}\\end\{smallmatrix\}\\right\.\\end\{aligned\}[Theorem˜4\.8](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem8)\(ours\)π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥1/2\\begin\{aligned\} \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}&=1\\\\\[\-1\.0pt\] \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}&\\geq 1/2\\end\{aligned\}[Theorem˜3\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem5)Kleinberg and Wei\([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)𝜸\\boldsymbol\{\\gamma\}\-Noveltyπ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥α\\begin\{aligned\} \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}&=1\\\\\[\-1\.0pt\] \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}&\\geq\\hskip\-1\.0pt\\alpha\\end\{aligned\}[Theorem˜I\.3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A9.Thmtheorem3)\(ours\)π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=1\\begin\{aligned\} \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}&=1\\\\\[\-1\.0pt\] \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}&=1\\end\{aligned\}[Corollary˜I\.4](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A9.Thmtheorem4)\(ours\)π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=1\\begin\{aligned\} \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}&=1\\\\\[\-1\.0pt\] \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}&=1\\end\{aligned\}[Theorem˜4\.9](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem9)\(ours\)π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=1\\begin\{aligned\} \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}&=1\\\\\[\-1\.0pt\] \\footnotesize\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}&=1\\end\{aligned\}[Corollary˜I\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A9.Thmtheorem2)\(ours\)Perfect tail precisionRelaxed tail precision

Figure 1:Overview of precision \(π^∗\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\) and recall \(ρ^∗\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\) bounds across settings defined by three constraints: novelty fraction withγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\)vs\. novelty, partial vs\. full adversarial exhaustion, and perfect tail precision \(τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\) vs\. relaxed tail precision \(τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}can be0\)\. Existing results are in blue and new results in green\.T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}is the target language and𝑻\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}is an enumeration ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. The adversary reveals a languageA⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}via an exhaustion𝑨\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}\. The learner outputs a guess languageG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}via the exhaustion𝑮\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\. In the full exhaustion setting, the adversary is restricted to revealing full exhaustions; in the partial setting, it may reveal a partial exhaustion\.𝑨\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}is characterized by lower and upper recall boundsρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)≥α\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\\geq\\alphaandρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)≤β\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\\leq\\beta\.Language identification in the limit is an influential learning paradigm\(Gold,[1967](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib1); Angluin,[1980](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib3)\)\. In the classic Gold–Angluin model, a learner observes an infinite stream of strings from a target languageT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, whereT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}is assumed to belong to a countable collection of languages𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}\. At each timestep, the learner outputs a hypothesis in𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}; it succeeds if there exists some finite \(but unknown\) time after which its hypotheses stabilize to the correct languageT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. In full generality, identification in this setting is impossible for most interesting collections of languages, i\.e\., even for regular languages\.Angluin \([1980](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib3)\)gave a characterization of the countable collections𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}that allow identification\. In recent work,Kleinberg and Mullainathan \([2024](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib2)\)introduced the paradigm of language*generation*in the limit, inspired by modern language models\. Again, the learner is given access to a countable collection of languages𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}\. Instead of identifying the target languageT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, it must produce, after some finite timestep, only*valid*\(belonging toT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\), previously unseen strings\. The authors showed that generation in the limit is tractable for any countable collection of languages𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}\.

While the algorithm ofKleinberg and Mullainathan \([2024](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib2)\)ensures validity, it leaves the question of*coverage*unexplored, i\.e\., how much ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}is generated\. A learner can satisfy the validity requirement by generating from some arbitrarily small, albeit still infinite, subset ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. In doing so, the learner avoids errors but fails to cover most ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Subsequent work formalized this tension, showing a trade\-off between coverage and validityCharikar and Pabbaraju \([2025](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib5)\)and establishing that achieving full coverage is as hard as language identificationKalavasiset al\.\([2025](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib9)\)\. Recently,Kleinberg and Wei \([2025a](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib4)\)introduced a notion of*density*\. In follow\-up work\(Kleinberg and Wei,[2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\), they prove that, in a partial enumeration setting, i\.e\., when the learner is shown strings from a subset of the target languageT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}with densityα\\alpha, a language can be generated with densityα/2\\nicefrac\{\{\\alpha\}\}\{\{2\}\}\.

We recast this problem as a recall–precision problem, starting from the observation that the coverage from previous work is equivalent to recall\. We introduce a complementary notion of precision that quantifies the learner’s error rate, better reflecting modern language\-modeling settings where occasional errors are unavoidable and the key question is their rate\. Because the standard definitions of precision and recall are ill\-defined for infinite sets, we define them via exhaustions, i\.e\., sequences of finite sets that approximate an infinite set\. We also formalize the validity requirement by introducing a notion that we call tail precision\.

We derive precision and recall bounds across a range of settings \(summarized in[Figure˜1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.F1)\), obtained by varying: \(i\) the fraction of strings that must be novel, \(ii\) whether the adversary reveals a full or only a partial exhaustion of the target language, and \(iii\) whether the learner is required to be eventually valid \(tail precision of one\)\. Several of these settings have not been studied previously\. Our main contributions and improvements over prior work are as follows\. First, in the partial enumeration setting with novelty and perfect tail precision, the best known recall bound is due toKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)\. We show that relaxing tail precision—allowing hallucinations at a vanishing rate—strictly improves recall whenever the adversary is sufficiently sparse\. In the most extreme case, where the adversary reveals almost nothing, our algorithm achieves coverage approaching one, while the no\-hallucination bound approaches zero\. Second, we introduce a continuous novelty parameter that interpolates between the strict novelty constraint and the no\-novelty setting, and give an algorithm with precision one and recall guarantees across the full spectrum\. This yields a new setting not studied in prior work: any fixed allowance of non\-novel outputs \(γ<1\\gamma<1\) allows generation in the limit with recall one and precision one\. As a technical contribution enabling these results, we generalize the algorithm ofKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)to a batched setting where the adversary can reveal multiple strings per round\.

## 2Approximate language learning

### 2\.1Preliminaries

Analphabetis a finite, non\-empty setΣ\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}\. Astring, denoted by𝒚\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}or𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}, is a finite sequence of symbols\. We writeℕ=def\{1,2,…\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{1,2,\\ldots\\\}for the positive integers andℕ0=def\{0,1,2,…\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\_\{0\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{0,1,2,\\ldots\\\}for the non\-negative integers\. The Kleene closure of an alphabetΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}is the set of all strings overΣ\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}\. AlanguageS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}is a subset ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\. We write\(Σ∗\)<ω\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\)^\{<\\omega\}for the set of all finite subsets ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\. We call a languagerecursively enumerableif there exists an algorithm \(Turing machine\) that lists exactly its elements \(possibly with repeats\), possibly never halting\. Anexhaustionis a sequence of finite sets𝑺=def\{Sn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\}\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}such thatS0=∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{0\}=\\emptysetandSn⊆Sn\+1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\+1\}for allnn\. We defineΔ​Sn=defSn∖Sn−1\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\-1\}\. We writeSn↑S=def⋃n=0∞Sn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\bigcup\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}to denote the limit of an exhaustion\. When the limitS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}is of relevance, we call𝑺\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\}\}an exhaustion*of*S\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\. Anenumerationof a languageS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}is an exhaustion𝑺=\{Sn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}with the property that\|Δ​Sn\|=1\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\|=1for alln∈ℕn\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\. Given a functionf:ℕ→ℕ0\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\\colon\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\\to\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\_\{0\}withlimN→∞∑n=1Nf​\(n\)=∞\\lim\_\{N\\to\\infty\}\\sum\_\{n=1\}^\{N\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\)=\\infty, anf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-boundedexhaustion is an exhaustion𝑺=\{Sn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}with the property that\|Δ​Sn\|≤f​\(n\)\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\|\\leq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\)for alln∈ℕn\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\. Iff​\(n\)=1\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\)=1, we call the exhaustion asingle\-stepexhaustion\. Iff​\(n\)=c\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\)=c, for a constantcc, we call the exhaustion acc\-stepexhaustion\. Given a languageS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}, we writeℰ​\(S\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\)\}to denote the set of all exhaustions ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\},ℰe​\(S\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\_\{e\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\)\}to denote the set of all enumerations ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}, andℰf​\(S\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\_\{f\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\)\}to denote the set of allf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded exhaustions ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\.

### 2\.2Approximate language learning

In this paper, we are interested in understanding how close one language is to another\. However, languages are, in general,*infinite*sets\. Consequently, cardinalities do not distinguish between small and large numbers of disagreements\. Moreover, sinceΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}is infinite, it admits no uniform distribution\. Thus, the error ratePr𝒚∼D⁡\[𝒚∈S∖S′\]\\Pr\_\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\\sim D\}\[\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\], for two languagesS,S′⊆Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}, is not well defined without choosing a particular distributionDDoverΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\.

#### A warm\-up\.

We first consider*finite*languages as a special case\. LetT⊂Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\subset\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}be a finitetarget language and letG⊂Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\subset\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}be a finiteguess language\. Under the standard definitions\(Manninget al\.,[2008](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib6)\), theprecisionofG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}with respect toT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}is the fraction of predicted strings that are correct, and therecallis the fraction of ground truth positives \(strings inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\) that are recovered,

π​\(T,G\)=def\|T∩G\|\|G\|,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\},\(1\)
ρ​\(T,G\)=def\|T∩G\|\|T\|\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\}\.\(2\)
The ratios used in precision and recall are not directly applicable to infinite sets since∞∞\\frac\{\\infty\}\{\\infty\}is not well\-defined in our setting\. Hence, we will make use of exhaustions to evaluate performance on increasing finite sets\. Intuitively, an exhaustion ofG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}models a learner’s successive predictions, while an exhaustion ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}corresponds to the finite subsets of the target language on which we assess the learner\. For the rest of the paper, we assumeG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}andT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}to be infinite\.

#### Exhaustion\-level precision\.

Let𝑻=\{Tn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be an exhaustion of the target languageT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, called atarget exhaustion, and let𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be an exhaustion of the guess languageG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}, calledguess exhaustion\. Then, define theupper precisionπ∗\\pi^\{\\ast\}and thelower precisionπ∗\\pi\_\{\\ast\}as

π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=deflim supn→∞\|Tn∩Gn\|\|Gn\|,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\limsup\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\},\(3\)
π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=deflim infn→∞\|Tn∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(4\)
When the upper and lower precision coincide, i\.e\.,π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}, we define theprecisionsimply asπ​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=deflimn→∞\|Tn∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\lim\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\. We show that precision does not always exist in[Example˜2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#Thmexample2)\.

#### Exhaustion\-level recall\.

Analogously to precision, we define theupper recallρ∗\\rho^\{\\ast\}andlower recallρ∗\\rho\_\{\\ast\}as

ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=deflim supn→∞\|Tn∩Gn\|\|Tn\|,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\limsup\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\},\(5\)
ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=deflim infn→∞\|Tn∩Gn\|\|Tn\|\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(6\)
When these coincide, we define therecallasρ​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=deflimn→∞\|Tn∩Gn\|\|Tn\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\lim\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\. Just like precision, recall does not always exist \(see[Example˜3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#Thmexample3)\)\.

#### Membership\-based precision\.

The precision notions above compare two*exhaustions*\. Validity, however, depends on membership inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}rather than membership in a particular finite prefixTn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}of some exhaustion\. To eliminate this arbitrary dependence on howT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}is exhausted, we define precision based on membership in the target language by taking the supremum over all exhaustions ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Since the limit need not exist, we use the lower and upper variants:

π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=defsup𝑻∈ℰ​\(T\)π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\),\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\},\(7\)
π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=defsup𝑻∈ℰ​\(T\)π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\.\(8\)
We primarily work withπ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}as a robust guarantee; all statements have direct analogues for the upper precision\. As we show next, this definition coincides with the intuitive membership\-based notion: it equals the lower asymptotic fraction of guess strings that lie inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.

###### Theorem 2\.1\.

Letf​\(n\):ℕ→ℕ\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\)\\colon\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\\to\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}be a function withlimN→∞∑n=1Nf​\(n\)=∞\\lim\_\{N\\to\\infty\}\\sum\_\{n=1\}^\{N\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\)=\\infty\. LetT⊆Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}be the target language and let𝐆=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be anf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded exhaustion of the guessG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. Then,

sup𝑻∈ℰf​\(T\)π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\.\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\_\{f\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(9\)

The proof is given in[Section˜B\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A2.SS2)\.

#### Coverage\-based recall\.

For recall, we are interested in understanding how many strings in the target languageT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}the learner actually recovers\. Hence, we check for each string inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}if it is included inG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. This is achieved by taking the supremum overG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. We define

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=sup𝑮∈ℰ​\(G\)ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\),\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\},\(10\)
ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=sup𝑮∈ℰ​\(G\)ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\.\(11\)
This definition assumes that we are given a fixed target exhaustion𝑻\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\. Again, we are mostly concerned with the lower recall as a robust guarantee; the following lemma holds analogously for upper recall\.

###### Lemma 2\.2\.

LetT⊆Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}be the target language with an exhaustion𝐓=\{Tn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}and letG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}be the guess language\. Then,

sup𝑮∈ℰ​\(G\)ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|Tn∩G\|\|Tn\|\.\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(12\)

The proof is given in[Section˜C\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A3.SS2)\.

#### Tail precision\.

The precision notions above are global: they measure the fraction of correct strings among*all*strings inGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\. Now we definetail precision, which considers only the incrementΔ​Gn\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\.

Let𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be an exhaustion\. For eachnn, define the step\-wise tail precisiontnt\_\{n\}as

tn=def\{1,if​\|Δ​Gn\|=0,\|T∩Δ​Gn\|\|Δ​Gn\|,otherwise\.t\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\begin\{cases\}1,&\\text\{if \}\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=0,\\\\ \\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\},&\\text\{otherwise\.\}\\end\{cases\}\(13\)
###### Definition 2\.3\.

Given a target languageT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}and a guess languageG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}with exhaustion𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}, we define thelower tail precisionandupper tail precisionas

τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=deflim infn→∞tn,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\},\(14\)
τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=deflim supn→∞tn\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\limsup\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\}\.\(15\)

Tail precision measures the asymptotic fraction of newly added strings that are inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.

###### Proposition 2\.4\.

LetT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}be the target language and𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}a single\-step exhaustion ofG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. Then,τ^∗​\(T,𝐆\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}is either0or11\. Moreover, for anycc\-step exhaustion𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\},τ^∗​\(T,𝐆\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}is attained after finitely many steps\.111This means that there exists a timestepn<∞n<\\infty, such that the step\-wise tail precisiontn=τ^∗​\(T,𝐆\)t\_\{n\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}andtN≥tnt\_\{N\}\\geq t\_\{n\}forN≥nN\\geq n\.

We give a proof in[Appendix˜D](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A4)\. For a functionf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}with non\-constant growth, one can distinguish between finite\-time stabilization to some constant and asymptotic convergence; the following example illustrates this\.

###### Example 1\.

Let\|Δ​Gn\|≤n\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\\leq n, i\.e\., at stepnnthe exhaustion𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}may grow by up tonnnew strings\. Suppose that at every step the increment contains exactlyn−1n\-1strings fromT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}and one string not inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Then,

τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|T∩Δ​Gn\|\|Δ​Gn\|=lim infn→∞n−1n=1,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{n\-1\}\{n\}=1,\(16\)i\.e\., the lower tail precision converges asymptotically to11, even though an error occurs at every step\. However, this ratio is never exactly11at any finite step\. Finite\-time stabilization to11would require that, from some step onward, every newly generated string lies inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, i\.e\.,Δ​Gn⊆T\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}for all sufficiently largenn\.

#### Relation toKleinberg and Wei \([2025a](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib4)\)\.

Our notion of coverage\-based recall is nearly identical to the density measure ofKleinberg and Wei \([2025a](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib4)\)\. In their setup, density is evaluated along a fixed enumeration𝑻=\{Tn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}\. In[Lemma˜2\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.Thmtheorem2), we derive[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib4)’s \([2025a](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib4)\) density measure of one languageG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}in anotherT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, corresponding to our definitions of lower \([Eq\.˜10](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.E10)\) and upper \([Eq\.˜11](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.E11)\) coverage\-based recall\. We extend their framework in two ways: \(i\) we allow*any*exhaustion rather than committing to a single fixed enumeration, and \(ii\) we introduce a complementary*precision*notion by exhausting the guessed language instead of the target\. In the next section, we instantiate these notions in the generation\-in\-the\-limit framework ofKleinberg and Mullainathan \([2024](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib2)\)\. In that setting, a generator’s output stream induces increasing prefix setsGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}of generated strings, and hence naturally defines an exhaustion ofG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. We will also formalize the eventual\-validity requirement from prior work by showing in[Proposition˜3\.3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem3)that it corresponds to*finite\-time stabilization*of tail precision to11\.

## 3Generation in the limit

We now introduce[Kleinberg and Mullainathan](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib2)’s \([2024](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib2)\) generation in the limit framework\. Let𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be a countable collection of languages𝒯⊆𝒫​\(Σ∗\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}\\subseteq\\mathcal\{P\}\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\)\. We assume that each languageS∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}is infinite\.222This is in line with[Kleinberg and Mullainathan](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib2)’s work and makes the generation of infinitely many unseen strings possible\.

An adversary chooses a target languageT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}and produces anf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded exhaustion𝑨=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}such thatAn⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}for allnn, andAn↑A\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}withA⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.Kleinberg and Mullainathan \([2024](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib2)\)assume a single\-step exhaustion; we extend their framework tof\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded exhaustions\. The adversary can repeat strings, and is not required to reveal a new string at each timestep; therefore,\|Δ​An\|\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\|can be0\. We call𝑨\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}afullexhaustion ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}ifA=T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, and apartialexhaustion otherwise \(A⊊T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subsetneq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\. In line withKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\), we assumeA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}to be infinite\. Ageneratoris a function𝒢:\(Σ∗\)<ω×\(Σ∗\)<ω→\(Σ∗\)<ω\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}\\colon\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\)^\{<\\omega\}\\times\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\)^\{<\\omega\}\\to\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\)^\{<\\omega\}\. Given an adversarial exhaustion𝑨=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}, the generator induces anf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-boundedgenerated exhaustion𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}via

G0=def∅,Gn=defGn−1∪𝒢​\(An,Gn−1\)\(n∈ℕ\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{0\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\emptyset,\\quad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\)\\quad\(n\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\)\.\(17\)At timennthe generator observes the currently revealed setAn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}and the previously generated setGn−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}, and appends one or multiple new strings\.Kleinberg and Mullainathan \([2024](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib2)\)demand that one new string is generated that is not inAn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\. Furthermore, their proposed algorithms also do not repeat strings inGn−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\. We writeGn↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}for the guess language\.

###### Definition 3\.1\(Generation in the limit\)\.

A generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}generates in the limitwith precisionλp\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\lambda\_\{p\}\}, recallλr\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\lambda\_\{r\}\}and tail precisionλt\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\lambda\_\{t\}\}for a collection of languages𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}if for everyT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}, every adversarial exhaustion𝐀=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofA⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, and𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}defined as in \([17](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.E17)\), it holds that

π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)≥λp,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\geq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\lambda\_\{p\}\},
ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥λr,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\lambda\_\{r\}\},
τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)≥λt\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\geq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\lambda\_\{t\}\}\.\(18\)

### 3\.1Perfect tail precision

Kleinberg and Mullainathan \([2024](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib2)\)require that after some finite timestep, all generated strings are valid \(i\.e\., belong toT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\. We refer to this property as*eventual validity*\.

###### Definition 3\.2\(Eventual Validity\)\.

A generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}iseventually validif there exists ann⋆n^\{\\star\}such that for alln≥n⋆n\\geq n^\{\\star\},

𝒢​\(An,Gn−1\)⊆T\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\)\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.\(19\)

Equivalently,\|G∖T\|<∞\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|<\\infty\. We show that eventual validity corresponds to finite\-time stabilization of tail precision to11\.

###### Proposition 3\.3\.

Let𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}be a generator and let𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}be the exhaustion it produces against the adversarial exhaustion𝐀\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}ofA⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Then𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}is eventually valid \(Def\.[3\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem2)\) if and only ifτ^∗​\(T,𝐆\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1is attained in finite time\.

###### Proof sketch\.

Intuitively, if the step\-wise tail precision is11from some finite time onward, then every newly generated string after that time lies in the target languageT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Hence, only finitely many mistakes can occur, and the generator is eventually valid\. Conversely, if only finitely many mistakes occur, then after the last mistake every newly generated string is valid, so the step\-wise tail precision is11from that point onward\. ∎

The full proof is in[Appendix˜D](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A4)\. In general, tail precision11automatically implies precision11\(see[Lemma˜D\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A4.Thmtheorem1)\)\. On the other hand, one may have precision11without convergence of tail precision to11: for example, if the generator outputs exactly one invalid string at timesn=2mn=2^\{m\}form∈ℕm\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}and a valid string otherwise, then the number of mistakes up to timennisΘ​\(log⁡n\)\\Theta\(\\log n\), so precision tends to11even though mistakes occur infinitely often, which yields tail precision0\.

### 3\.2Generation with novelty

###### Definition 3\.4\(Novelty constraint\)\.

A generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}isnovelif for everyn≥1n\\geq 1,

𝒢​\(An,Gn−1\)∩\(An∪Gn−1\)=∅\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\)\\cap\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\)=\\emptyset\.\(20\)

In words, once a string has been seen—meaning that it has been either revealed in someAn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}or it has been generated by someGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}—it becomes permanently unavailable to the generator\. This modeling choice makes achieving high recall non\-trivial\. Without it, a generator could simply copy the adversary and achieve perfect recall and perfect precision whenever the adversary fully enumeratesT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\(see[Theorem˜E\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A5.Thmtheorem1)\)\. Under a novel generator, however, the adversary can*steal*strings by revealing them first, which imposes an inherent ceiling on recall\. We restate, in our notation, the following recall bounds fromKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)\.

###### Theorem 3\.5\.

\[Kleinberg and Wei[2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Thm\. 3\.5\] Let𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be a countable collection of languages andT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}a target language\. Fix an enumeration𝐓=\{Tn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. There exists a novel generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}that generates in the limit forT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}withτ^∗​\(T,𝐆\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1, such that the following holds: For every single\-step adversarial exhaustion𝐀=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, the generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}induces a single\-step exhaustion𝐆=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withGn↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}satisfying

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥12​ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq\\frac\{1\}\{2\}\\,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\.\(21\)

By[Proposition˜2\.4](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.Thmtheorem4),τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}converges in finite time to11in this setting\. As a special case,[Theorem˜3\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem5)implies that for a full, single\-step exhaustion of the target language, an algorithm can generate with recall12\\tfrac\{1\}\{2\}\.

###### Theorem 3\.6\.

\[Kleinberg and Wei[2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Thm\. 3\.3\] The constant12\\tfrac\{1\}\{2\}in[Theorem˜3\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem5)is optimal: for every novel generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}there exist a countable collection𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}, a target languageT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}with enumeration𝐓\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}, and a single\-step adversarial exhaustion𝐀=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}such that, if𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}induces a single\-step exhaustion𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}, then

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≤12​ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\leq\\frac\{1\}\{2\}\\,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\.\(22\)

In practice, forbidding the generator from outputting previously revealed strings is not always desirable: repeating training data can be necessary \(e\.g\., when quoting a source\)\. Motivated by this observation, we introduce the following continuous relaxation of the novelty constraint\.

###### Definition 3\.7\(γ\\gamma\-novelty\)\.

Letγ∈\[0,1\]\\gamma\\in\[0,1\]\. Given an adversarial exhaustion𝐀=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}and the generated exhaustion𝐆=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}, define

N0:=∅,Nn:=Nn−1∪\(Δ​Gn∖An\)\.N\_\{0\}:=\\emptyset,\\qquad N\_\{n\}:=N\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\\bigl\(\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\bigr\)\.\(23\)We say that the generator isγ\\gamma\-novel if, for everynnwith\|Gn\|\>0\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\>0,

\|Nn\|\|Gn\|≥γ\.\\frac\{\|N\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\geq\\gamma\.\(24\)

In words,γ\\gamma\-novelty requires that everyGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}contains at least aγ\\gamma\-fraction of strings that were novel at the time they were first generated, i\.e\., strings that had not already been revealed by the adversary and had not already been generated\. Equivalently, at most a\(1−γ\)\(1\-\\gamma\)\-fraction of the strings in anyGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}may be non\-novel\. We defineγ\\gamma\-novelty forγ∈\[0,1\]\\gamma\\in\[0,1\]\. Forγ=0\\gamma=0, this imposes no novelty restriction, while the endpointγ=1\\gamma=1coincides with the strict novelty constraint of[Definition˜3\.4](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem4)\. We treat novelty \(γ=1\\gamma=1\) separately from the relaxed regimeγ<1\\gamma<1\(see[Figure˜1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.F1)\)\.

We studyγ\\gamma\-novel generation in the limit under varying tail\-precision assumptions in[Section˜4](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4)\. We show that the relaxationγ<1\\gamma<1is already sufficient to recover all adversarially revealed strings, and, when perfect tail precision is not required, to achieve both precision and recall equal to11\.

## 4Generating with infinitely many hallucinations

Existing results aim to maximize recall for novel generators with perfect tail precision, yielding guarantees such as the12\\tfrac\{1\}\{2\}bound ofKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)\(restated in[Theorems˜3\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem5)and[3\.6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem6)\)\. In this section, we ask how these limits change once we relax the tail precision constraint: rather than requiring that only finitely many hallucinations occur, we allow infinitely many hallucinations provided they occur at a vanishing rate\. In this regime, tail precision can even be0, but precision is11in the limit\.

In line withKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\), we assume a fixed enumeration𝑻=\{Tn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}and single\-step exhaustions𝑨=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}and𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withGn↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}, i\.e\., both the adversary and the generator are allowed to produce at most one string per round\. In contrast, an enumeration adds exactly one new string at every round\. Our results for generation without novelty \(γ=0\\gamma=0\) hold for a more general setting where both𝑨\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}and𝑮\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}aref\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded\. We characterize the adversary’s exhaustion by the lower and upper recall:

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)≥α,ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)≤β\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\\geq\\alpha,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\\leq\\beta\.\(25\)Intuitively, the lower recall measures how much of the target language the adversary eventually reveals, while the upper recall captures how large the revealed set can appear along subsequences\. We also fix a total order≺\\preconΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}and write𝒙≺𝒚\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\prec\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}if𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}is≺\\prec\-smaller than𝒚\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\.

We first analyze this setting without and with the novelty constraint \(γ=0\\gamma=0vs\.γ=1\\gamma=1\), and then give aγ\\gamma\-novel algorithm and guarantees forγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\)\. Our constructions share the same template: We run asafegenerator \(outputting fromT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\) most of the time, and interleave it with rareexplorationrounds that enumerateΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}to recover strings the adversary never reveals\. Exploration rounds may output invalid strings, but we schedule them sparsely, yielding precision11\. To achieve this, we will make use ofexploration sets\.

###### Definition 4\.1\(Exploration set\)\.

Anexploration setis an infinite setR⊂ℕ\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\subset\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}such that1∉R1\\notin\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}and no two consecutive integers belong toR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\. Form∈ℕm\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}, definer​\(m\)=def\|R∩\{1,…,m\}\|\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\)\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\bigl\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\cap\\\{1,\\dots,m\\\}\\bigr\|\.We require thatr​\(m\)/m→0\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\)/m\\to 0asm→∞m\\to\\infty\.

An example isR=\{2i:i∈ℕ\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}=\\\{2^\{i\}\\colon i\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\\\}\.

For theγ\\gamma\-novel algorithm, we need exploration rounds to be sparse not only asymptotically, but in every finite prefix\. We therefore introduce the following strengthened notion\.

###### Definition 4\.2\(γ\\gamma\-admissible exploration set\)\.

Letγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\)\. An infinite exploration setR⊆ℕ\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}isγ\\gamma\-admissibleif, for everym∈ℕm\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\},r​\(m\)≤\(1−γ\)​m\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\)\\leq\(1\-\\gamma\)m\.

We show the existence of such sets for everyγ<1\\gamma<1in[Lemma˜I\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A9.Thmtheorem1)\.

### 4\.1Generation without novelty \(γ=0\\gamma=0\)

We first considerγ=0\\gamma=0, dropping the novelty constraint entirely, which serves as a useful baseline\. In this regime, repeating the adversary’s strings is allowed at any time, and the generator can combine \(i\) parroting the adversary to keep precision high and \(ii\) sparse exploration to achieve perfect recall, even for partial exhaustions𝑨\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}\.

###### Theorem 4\.3\.

Let𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be a countable collection of languages andT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}a target language\. Fix an enumeration𝐓=\{Tn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. There exists a generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}, such that, for anyf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded adversarial exhaustion𝐀=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, the generated exhaustion𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}isf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded and satisfies:

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=1,π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=1,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\.\(26\)

The proof is in[Section˜E\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A5.SS2)\. Note that this theorem holds for both full and partial exhaustion of the targetT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.

### 4\.2Generation with novelty \(γ=1\\gamma=1\)

We now reinstate novelty \([Definition˜3\.4](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem4)\), considering the other extreme of the spectrum, where it is not allowed to repeat any string that has been revealed before\. Hence, the adversary can*steal*strings by revealing them first, making perfect recall unattainable\. Our goal is to understand how far recall can be pushed when we drop perfect tail precision, but aim to generate with precision11\. Our generator combines two complementary mechanisms:

1. 1\.Exploration roundsrecover the non\-stolen portion\. If a string is never revealed by the adversary \(i\.e\., it lies inT∖A\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\), then it is never blocked by novelty\. Hence, an exploration routine that enumeratesΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}while skipping already\-seen strings will eventually output it\.
2. 2\.Safe roundsrecover recall proportional toα\\alpha, whenρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)≥α\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\\geq\\alpha\. We run aKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)\-style generator whose tail precision converges to11, which will be the key ingredient for achieving precision11\.

In this setting, there can be up to two adversarial revelations between two safe outputs\. Therefore, we first need to adapt[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)’s \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\) algorithm to a so\-calledkk\-batched adversarial setting \(withk=2k=2here\)\.

###### Definition 4\.4\.

Consider a setting in which the adversary iskk\-step bounded, i\.e\., it can reveal at mostkknew strings per stepnn, and the generator is single\-step bounded\. We call this setting akk\-batched adversarial setting\.

[Algorithm˜2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg2)shows[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)’s \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\) algorithm for generation in the limit\.333Note that they require𝑨\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}and𝑮\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}to be single\-step exhaustions\.At timenn, consider all hypotheses that are consistent with the strings revealed by the adversary, i\.e\., all languagesS∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}withAn⊆S\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\. Intersecting these consistent hypotheses in a global order, given by a fixed listing\(Si′\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}of all languages in𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}, yields a decreasing*intersection chain*Cn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\(see[Algorithm˜3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg3)\)\. Early sets in the chain are larger \(better for recall\), but riskier, while later sets are smaller \(safer\), but might miss many valid strings\. The*identified intersection*procedure \(see[Algorithm˜4](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg4)\) selects a particular memberℐ\(n\)∈Cn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}that behaves stably over time: after some finite time, it is a subset of the true targetT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\(eventual validity\), it is comparable across rounds, and it is*full*\(containsA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\) infinitely often\. Intuitively,ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}is designed to be a tractable candidate set of strings deemed safe givenAn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\. However, outputting only fromℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}can hurt recall, becauseℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}may shrink temporarily when the adversary reveals new strings, making the generator too conservative in those rounds\. To mitigate this, the algorithm chooses an*aggressive set*ℐ~\(n\)\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}, which is either the current identified intersection or a carefully chosen larger fallback from recent rounds \(see[Algorithm˜5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg5)\)\. After some finite time—once the identified intersections are valid and comparable—this fallback simplifies toℐ~\(n\)∈\{ℐ\(n\),ℐ\(n−1\)\}⊆T\.\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\in\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\},\\,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\\\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.Thusℐ~\(n\)\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}is also eventually valid, but can be temporarily larger thanℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}, allowing the generator to improve recall\. However,ℐ~\(n\)\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}itself evolves, so a string that appears safe at roundnnmight no longer be among preferred candidates at roundn\+1n\+1ifℐ~\(n\)\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}shrinks\. This problem is addressed bypods\. In each roundnn, the algorithm creates a podPn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}of sizesns\_\{n\}with thesns\_\{n\}≺\\prec\-smallest*unused*strings ofℐ~\(n\)\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\(excluding strings already revealed, output, or in previous pods\) and adds those strings into a global*pod pool*\. In each round, the generator outputs the≺\\prec\-smallest element from the pool\. This pool is crucial for achieving high recall: Even ifℐ~\(n\)\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}shrinks later, strings that were previously added to pods are not lost and can eventually be output\.

We first generalize[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)’s \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\) pods algorithm \(see[Algorithm˜2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg2)\) and the corresponding recall bound for akk\-batched setting, assuming that𝑨\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}is akk\-step exhaustion\.

###### Lemma 4\.5\.

Assume akk\-batched adversarial setting, withk≥2k\\geq 2\. For anyT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}and anykk\-batched exhaustion𝐀\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}ofA⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}with lower recallρ^∗​\(𝐓,A\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}, the exhaustion𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}generated by applying[Algorithm˜2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg2)satisfies the novelty constraint and achieves

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥1k\+1​ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\),\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq\\ \\frac\{1\}\{k\+1\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\},\(27a\)π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1,τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\.\(27b\)

###### Proof sketch\.

First, note that[Algorithm˜2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg2)outputs only from the current pod pool𝒫n\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}, which is populated with≺\\prec\-small unused elements from aggressive sets\. Thus, the generator is novel\. Denote by𝒫\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}the set of all strings that are ever placed in a pod\. We relate the adversary’s revealed strings to the generator’s outputs via a two\-step charging argument\. First, consider strings inA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}that are neither output nor ever placed into a pod \(not in𝒫\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\)\. Using that \(after finite steps\) the identified intersection is valid and is full infinitely often, one can show: for each such missed string, earlier pods contain many≺\\prec\-smaller unused candidates\. Formally, we can charge each missed𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}to a pod indexρ​\(𝒙\)\\rho\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)whose pod contains at leastsselements all≺𝒙\\prec\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}, and because the adversary introduces at mostkknew strings per round, each pod index receives at mostkkcharges\. Hence the total number of such missed strings up toTn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}is at mostks​\|𝒫∩Tn\|\+𝒪​\(n\)\\frac\{k\}\{s\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(n\)\. Second, we control the backlog in the pod pool\. Since the algorithm outputs one element per round and the adversary reveals at mostkknew strings per round, the number of adversary strings that can accumulate in the pool without being output is at most a factorkklarger than the number of outputs\. We can charge every pooled string that appears inA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}but not inG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}to a nearby generator output\. Each output receives at mostkksuch charges\. Combining this with the first charging step yields\|A∩Tn\|≤\(k\+1\+𝒪​\(1\)\)​\|G∩Tn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\\leq\(k\+1\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(1\)\)\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\. Dividing by\|Tn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|, takinglim inf\\liminf, and letting the pod\-size parameters→∞s\\to\\inftygivesρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥1k\+1​ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq\\frac\{1\}\{k\+1\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\. The tail precision and precision are11, as[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)’s \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\) algorithm guarantees that from a finite step onward everyΔ​Gn\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}is inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.∎

Full proof in[Appendix˜G](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7)\. The following lemma provides a matching upper bound on the lower recall of any novel generator, generalizingKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Theorem 3\.3\)to thekk\-batched setting\. Together with[Lemma˜4\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem5), this shows that the factor1k\+1\\frac\{1\}\{k\+1\}is worst\-case optimal\.

###### Lemma 4\.6\.

Assume akk\-batched adversarial setting\. There exist countable collections of languages𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}, such that for a targetT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}and an adversarial exhaustion𝐀\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}withAn↑A\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, andA⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, the recall of any novel generator that satisfiesτ^∗​\(T,𝐆\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1is bounded by

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≤ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)k\+1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\leq\\frac\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\}\{k\+1\}\.\(28\)

The full proof is given in[Section˜G\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.SS2)\. We now move to examining the contribution of exploration rounds: if a generator eventually outputs every string in the target language that the adversary never reveals, then recall is at least1−β1\-\\beta\.

###### Lemma 4\.7\.

LetT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be the target, and𝐀\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}an exhaustion produced by the adversary withρ^∗​\(𝐓,A\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\. Assume that𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}contains every element inT∖A\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}at some point\. Then

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥1−ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq 1\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\.\(29\)

###### Proof\.

AsT∖A⊆G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}, we get

\|G∩Tn\|\|Tn\|≥\|T∖A∩Tn\|\|Tn\|≥1−\|A∩Tn\|\|Tn\|\.\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\ \\geq\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\geq 1\-\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(30\)Takinglim infn→∞\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}on the left and usinglim infn→∞\(1−an\)=1−lim supn→∞\(an\)\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\(1\-a\_\{n\}\)=1\-\\limsup\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\(a\_\{n\}\)gives

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)\\displaystyle\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}≥1−lim supn→∞\|A∩Tn\|\|Tn\|\\displaystyle\\geq 1\-\\limsup\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\(31a\)=1−ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)\.\\displaystyle=1\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\.\(31b\)∎

We now present[Algorithm˜6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg6), which alternates safe rounds with exploration rounds at timesm∈Rm\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\. On safe rounds, we execute one step of the batchedKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)routine: update the consistent chain, add a new pod from the aggressive set to the global pod pool, and output the≺\\prec\-smallest unused pool element\. On exploration rounds, we output the next string in the fixed enumeration𝑬\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{E\}\}ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}, skipping previously seen strings to enforce novelty\. Since exploration does not advance the safe routine, the safe routine perceives a22\-batched adversary\.

###### Theorem 4\.8\.

For anyT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}and any single\-step adversarial exhaustion𝐀\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}with lower recallρ^∗​\(𝐓,A\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}and upper recallρ^∗​\(𝐓,A\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}, Algorithm[6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg6)generating𝐆=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withGn↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}achieves precision11and recall

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥max⁡\(1−ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\),ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)3\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq\\ \\max\\Big\(1\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\},\\frac\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\}\{3\}\\Big\)\.\(32\)

###### Proof sketch\.

By construction,[Algorithm˜6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg6)eventually outputs every string inT∖A\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, which yields recall at least1−β1\-\\beta\(cf\.[Lemma˜4\.7](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem7)\)\. Moreover, the safe routine is invoked in a22\-batched manner, implying an additional recall guarantee of at leastα/3\\alpha/3from the safe rounds \([Lemma˜4\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem5)\)\. These two contributions cannot, in general, be added: it may occur that both the safe and the exploration rounds output only strings fromT∖A\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\. Precision11follows because the safe routine outputs only strings fromT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}after some finite time, and the exploration rounds are scheduled at a vanishing rate\. ∎

Full proof in[Section˜H\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A8.SS1)\. The term1−β1\-\\betadominates when the adversary reveals only a small portion of the target along some subsequence \(i\.e\.,β\\betais small\), since exploration can then recover almost all strings inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}that are never stolen\. Overall,[Algorithm˜6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg6)can improve recall, particularly in regimes whereα\\alphaandβ\\betaare small\. Finally, in the setting where the adversary presents a full exhaustion ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, the originalKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)bound cannot be improved\.

### 4\.3Generation withγ\\gamma\-novelty forγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\)

With[Algorithm˜7](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg7), we provide an adaptation of[Algorithm˜6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg6)that satisfiesγ\\gamma\-novelty forγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\)and leads to higher recall guarantees\. Concretely,[Algorithm˜7](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg7)differs from[Algorithm˜6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg6)in two ways: \(i\) the exploration setR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}is required to beγ\\gamma\-admissible, and \(ii\) on exploration rounds, the algorithm skips only strings that have already been generated, rather than also skipping strings revealed by the adversary\. Thus, an exploration output may be non\-novel if it has previously been revealed by the adversary\. SinceR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}isγ\\gamma\-admissible, the number of such non\-novel outputs remains within the allowed quota\. We show that for everyγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\), precision and recall equal to11can be achieved\.

###### Theorem 4\.9\.

Fix anyγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\)\. For anyT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}and any single\-step adversarial exhaustion𝐀\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},[Algorithm˜7](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg7)generates aγ\\gamma\-novel exhaustion𝐆=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withGn↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}such that

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=1,π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=1,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\.\(33\)

###### Proof sketch\.

The modified exploration rounds enumerate all ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}, skipping only strings that have already been generated\. Hence, every string inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}is eventually generated, which yields recall11\. Precision is11because safe rounds are eventually valid, while exploration rounds occur at a vanishing rate\. Finally, non\-novel outputs can occur only in exploration rounds\. Since the exploration set isγ\\gamma\-admissible, the fraction of novel outputs inGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}for eachnnis at leastγ\\gammaand hence the generated exhaustion isγ\\gamma\-novel for every fixedγ<1\\gamma<1\. The full proof is given in[Section˜I\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A9.SS1)\. ∎

## 5Conclusion

We recast generation in the limit as a precision–recall problem\. We introduce a precision metric based on asymptotic error rates that remains informative even under infinite errors, and formalize eventual validity as the*finite\-time*stabilization of tail precision to11\. We study generation in different settings, including the relaxations of the novelty constraint and of perfect tail precision, moving toward settings that better reflect how large language models generate\. Our main finding is that allowing hallucinations at a vanishing rate provides an advantage over eventually valid generators, but only when the adversary permanently withholds a large portion of the target language\. In this regime, exploration rounds can recover hidden strings while keeping the error rate under control\. We also introduce a continuous novelty parameter and find that any fixed allowance of non\-novel strings allows both perfect precision and perfect recall when the perfect tail precision requirement is relaxed\.

## References

- D\. Angluin \(1980\)Inductive inference of formal languages from positive data\.Information and Control45\(2\),pp\. 117–135\.External Links:[Link](https://doi.org/10.1016/S0019-9958(80)90285-5)Cited by:[§1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.p1.10)\.
- M\. Charikar and C\. Pabbaraju \(2025\)Exploring facets of language generation in the limit\.InProceedings of Thirty Eighth Conference on Learning Theory,Proceedings of Machine Learning Research, Vol\.291,pp\. 854–887\.External Links:[Link](https://proceedings.mlr.press/v291/charikar25a.html)Cited by:[§1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.p2.6)\.
- E\. M\. Gold \(1967\)Language identification in the limit\.Information and Control10\(5\),pp\. 447–474\.External Links:[Link](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0019995867911655)Cited by:[§1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.p1.10)\.
- A\. Kalavasis, A\. Mehrotra, and G\. Velegkas \(2025\)On characterizations for language generation: interplay of hallucinations, breadth, and stability\.External Links:[Link](http://arxiv.org/abs/2412.18530)Cited by:[§1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.p2.6)\.
- J\. Kleinberg and S\. Mullainathan \(2024\)Language generation in the limit\.InAdvances in Neural Information Processing Systems,Vol\.37\.External Links:[Link](https://proceedings.neurips.cc/paper_files/paper/2024/file/7988e9b3876ad689e921ce05d711442f-Paper-Conference.pdf),2404\.06757Cited by:[§1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.p1.10),[§1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.p2.6),[§2\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.SS2.SSS0.Px7.p1.6),[§3\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.SS1.p1.1),[§3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.p1.3),[§3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.p2.19),[§3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.p2.25),[footnote 2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#footnote2)\.
- J\. Kleinberg and F\. Wei \(2025a\)Density measures for language generation\.In2025 IEEE 66th Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science \(FOCS\),pp\. 620–658\.External Links:[Link](https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/11369227)Cited by:[§1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.p2.6),[§2\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.SS2.SSS0.Px7),[§2\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.SS2.SSS0.Px7.p1.6)\.
- J\. Kleinberg and F\. Wei \(2025b\)Language generation and identification from partial enumeration: tight density bounds and topological characterizations\.External Links:[Link](https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.05295)Cited by:[Appendix F](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A6.SS0.SSS0.Px1.p1.3),[Appendix F](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A6.SS0.SSS0.Px1.p2.1),[Appendix F](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A6.SS0.SSS0.Px2.p2.3),[Appendix F](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A6.SS0.SSS0.Px2.p3.3),[Appendix F](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A6.SS0.SSS0.Px3.p1.10),[Appendix F](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A6.p1.8),[Appendix F](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A6.p2.1),[§G\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.SS1.1.p1.5),[§G\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.SS1.SSS0.Px1.p1.5),[§G\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.SS1.SSS0.Px2.p1.1),[§G\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.SS1.SSS0.Px4.p1.2),[§G\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.SS1.SSS0.Px6.1.p1.21),[§G\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.SS1.SSS0.Px6.3.p3.7),[§H\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A8.SS1.SSS0.Px2.p2.3),[§H\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A8.SS1.SSS0.Px3.p1.5),[§I\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A9.SS2.2.p1.12),[§I\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A9.SS2.SSS0.Px2.p1.6),[Figure 1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.F1.1.pic1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.4),[Figure 1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.F1.1.pic1.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.2.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.4),[Figure 1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.F1.1.pic1.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.4.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.4),[§1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.p2.6),[§1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S1.p4.1),[§3\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.SS2.p1.3),[Theorem 3\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem5.p1.12.12),[Theorem 3\.6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem6.p1.9.9),[§3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.p2.19),[item 2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.I1.i2.p1.4),[§4\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.SS2.2.p1.27),[§4\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.SS2.p2.2),[§4\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.SS2.p3.29),[§4\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.SS2.p4.3),[§4\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.SS2.p5.2),[§4\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.SS2.p7.5),[§4\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.SS2.p8.6),[§4](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.p1.3),[§4](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.p2.9),[Algorithm 2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg2)\.
- C\. D\. Manning, P\. Raghavan, and H\. Schütze \(2008\)Introduction to information retrieval\.Cambridge University Press\.External Links:[Link](https://www.cambridge.org/highereducation/books/introduction-to-information-retrieval/669D108D20F556C5C30957D63B5AB65C)Cited by:[§2\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.SS2.SSS0.Px1.p1.5)\.
- T\. Radó \(1962\)On non\-computable functions\.Bell System Technical Journal41\(3\),pp\. 877–884\.External Links:[Link](https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1538-7305.1962.tb00480.x)Cited by:[Appendix A](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A1.p1.17)\.

## Appendix AComputability of exhaustions

We call an exhaustion𝑺=def\{Sn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\}\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}computable if there exists an algorithm \(Turing machine\) that emitsSn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}in order\. Note that an exhaustion may fail to be computable even if its limit language is\. LetS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}be an infinite computable language, and write𝒚1≺𝒚2≺⋯\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\_\{1\}\\prec\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\_\{2\}\\prec\\cdotsfor the elements ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}in lexicographic order\. Define an exhaustion𝑺=def\{Sn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\}\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}bySn=def\{𝒚1,…,𝒚BB​\(n\)\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\_\{1\},\\ldots,\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathrm\{BB\}\(n\)\}\}\\\}, whereBB​\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathrm\{BB\}\(n\)\}denotes the busy beaver function\. If𝑺\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\}\}were computable, we could run a Turing machine emittingSn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}in order until it outputs thenthn^\{\\text\{th\}\}set\. Returning its cardinality\|Sn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\|would compute the busy beaver function, contradicting the fact that it is not computable\(Radó,[1962](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib7)\)\. However, iff\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}and the limit languageS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}are computable, one can construct a computablef\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded exhaustion ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}, provided thatf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}allows for enough cumulative capacity\.

We denote the set of computable exhaustions ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}byℰC​\(S\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\_\{\\mathrm\{C\}\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\)\}\. Computable exhaustions imply that the language is recursively enumerable, as shown in the following lemma\.

###### Lemma A\.1\.

LetS⊆Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}and let𝐒=\{Sn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be an exhaustion ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\. If𝐒\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\}\}is computable, thenS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}is recursively enumerable\.

###### Proof\.

We will construct a Turing Machine that enumeratesS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\. Since𝑺\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\}\}is computable, there exists a Turing machineMMthat emits \(in order\) a finite description ofS1,S2,…\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{2\},\\ldots\. This can be eachSn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}output as a finite list of strings with separators and an end marker\.

We construct an enumeratorEEforS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}as follows\. RunMM\. WheneverMMfinishes emitting the description ofSn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}, decode this finite description and print every string inSn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}\(to an output tape\), then continue runningMMto obtainSn\+1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\+1\}, and so on\.

We show thatEEenumerates exactlyS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\.

\(*Soundness*\) Every string printed byEEbelongs to someSn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}, hence belongs to⋃k=1∞Sk=S\\bigcup\_\{k=1\}^\{\\infty\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{k\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\.

\(*Completeness*\) Let𝒙∈S\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\. SinceS=⋃n=1∞Sn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}=\\bigcup\_\{n=1\}^\{\\infty\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{n\}, there existsNNsuch that𝒙∈SN\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{N\}\. WhenMMemitsSN\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{N\}, the machineEEprints all elements ofSN\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{N\}, in particular𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\. Thus every element ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}is eventually printed byEE\.

ThereforeEElists exactly the elements ofS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\(possibly with repeats\), soS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}is recursively enumerable\. ∎

## Appendix BPrecision

### B\.1Exhaustion\-level precision

###### Example 2\(Precision need not exist\)\.

LetΣ=\{a,b\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}=\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\},\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}b\}\}\\\}\. Define the target languageT=def\{an∣n∈ℕ\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}^\{n\}\\mid n\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\\\}with an exhaustion𝐓\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},

Tn=def\{ai∣1≤i≤n\}\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}^\{i\}\\mid 1\\leq i\\leq n\\\}\.\(34\)Let the guess language beG=defT∪\{bn∣n∈ℕ\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cup\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}b\}\}^\{n\}\\mid n\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\\\}and define an exhaustion

Gn=def\{a1,…,an\}∪\{b1,…,b2⌊log2⁡n⌋\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}^\{1\},\\dots,\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}^\{n\}\\\}\\ \\cup\\ \\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}b\}\}^\{1\},\\dots,\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}b\}\}^\{2^\{\\lfloor\\log\_\{2\}n\\rfloor\}\}\\\},\(35\)i\.e\., at timennwe include alla\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}\-strings up to lengthnnand allb\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}b\}\}\-strings up to the largest power of22not exceedingnn\. ThenGn⊆Gn\+1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\+1\}andGn↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. BecauseTn⊆Gn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}and thea\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}\-strings andb\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}b\}\}\-strings are disjoint,

\|Tn∩Gn\|=\|Tn\|=n,\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|=n,\(36\)
\|Gn\|=n\+2⌊log2⁡n⌋,\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=n\+2^\{\\lfloor\\log\_\{2\}n\\rfloor\},\(37\)

and therefore, we obtain

pn=def\|Tn∩Gn\|\|Gn\|,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}p\_\{n\}\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\},\(38\)pn=nn\+2⌊log2⁡n⌋\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}p\_\{n\}\}=\\frac\{n\}\{n\+2^\{\\lfloor\\log\_\{2\}n\\rfloor\}\}\.\(39\)Evaluatingpn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}p\_\{n\}\}along two subsequences gives different limit points, as we can see below\.

limm→∞p2m\\displaystyle\\lim\_\{m\\to\\infty\}p\_\{2^\{m\}\}=limm→∞2m2m\+2m=12,\\displaystyle=\\lim\_\{m\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{2^\{m\}\}\{2^\{m\}\+2^\{m\}\}=\\frac\{1\}\{2\},\(40a\)limm→∞p2m\+1−1\\displaystyle\\lim\_\{m\\to\\infty\}p\_\{2^\{m\+1\}\-1\}=limm→∞2m\+1−1\(2m\+1−1\)\+2m=23\.\\displaystyle=\\lim\_\{m\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{2^\{m\+1\}\-1\}\{\(2^\{m\+1\}\-1\)\+2^\{m\}\}=\\frac\{2\}\{3\}\.\(40b\)Thus, by the definitions oflim inf\\liminfandlim sup\\limsup,

π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)\\displaystyle\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=lim infn→∞pn≤12,\\displaystyle=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}p\_\{n\}\}\\leq\\frac\{1\}\{2\},\(41a\)π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)\\displaystyle\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=lim supn→∞pn≥23,\\displaystyle=\\limsup\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}p\_\{n\}\}\\geq\\frac\{2\}\{3\},\(41b\)so the limit defining precision does not exist\.

### B\.2Membership\-based precision

###### Lemma B\.1\.

LetT⊆Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}be the target language and let𝐆=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be an exhaustion of the guess languageG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. Then,

sup𝑻∈ℰ​\(T\)π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\.\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(42\)

###### Proof\.

We prove the lemma in two parts\.

Part 1 \(supT∈ℰ​\(T\)π∗​\(T,G\)≤lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\leq\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\)\.Choose𝑻∈ℰ​\(T\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}arbitrarily\. BecauseTn⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}for allnn, we have\|Tn∩Gn\|≤\|T∩Gn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\\leq\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|for everynn\. Dividing by\|Gn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|and takinglim inf\\liminfyields

π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|Tn∩Gn\|\|Gn\|≤lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\leq\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(43\)Taking the supremum over𝑻∈ℰ​\(T\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}proves

sup𝑻∈ℰ​\(T\)π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)≤lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\.\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\\ \{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\leq\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(44\)
Part 2 \(lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|≤supT∈ℰ​\(T\)π∗​\(T,G\)\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\leq\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\)\.

Fix an enumeration𝒀=\{Yn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{Y\}\}=\\\{Y\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withYn↑TY\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. We define an exhaustion𝑻⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}^\{\\star\}\. For eachn∈ℕn\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}, define

Tn⋆=def\(T∩Gn\)∪Yn\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\)\\ \\cup\\ Y\_\{n\}\.\(45\)Note that eachTn⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}is finite,Tn⋆⊆Tn\+1⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\+1\}^\{\\star\}, andTn⋆↑T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Thus,𝑻⋆∈ℰ​\(T\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}^\{\\star\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\. Moreover,

Tn⋆∩Gn=\(\(T∩Gn\)∪Yn\)∩Gn=\(T∩Gn\)∪\(Yn∩Gn\)=\(T∪Yn\)∩Gn=T∩Gn\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\\bigl\(\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\)\\cup Y\_\{n\}\\bigr\)\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\)\\cup\(Y\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\)=\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cup Y\_\{n\}\)\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\.\(46\)where the last equality usesYn⊆TY\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}for alln≥0n\\geq 0\. Hence,\|Tn⋆∩Gn\|\|Gn\|=\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}for alln≥0n\\geq 0\. Takinglim inf\\liminfyields

π∗​\(𝑻⋆,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|Tn⋆∩Gn\|\|Gn\|=lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}^\{\\star\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\},\(47\)which proves the reverse inequality in[Eq\.˜42](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A2.E42)asπ∗​\(𝑻⋆,𝑮\)≤sup𝑻∈ℰ​\(T\)π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}^\{\\star\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\leq\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\. ∎

An analogous property holds for upper precision\.

###### Lemma B\.2\.

LetT⊆Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}be the target language and let𝐆=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be an exhaustion of the guess languageG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. Then,

sup𝑻∈ℰ​\(T\)π∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=lim supn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\.\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\limsup\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(48\)

###### Proof\.

Analogous to proof of[Lemma˜B\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A2.Thmtheorem1)\. ∎

See[2\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.Thmtheorem1)

###### Proof\.

We prove the theorem in two parts\.

Part 1 \(supT∈ℰf​\(T\)π∗​\(T,G\)≤lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\_\{f\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\leq\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\)\.This is analogous to the proof of Part 1 in[Lemma˜B\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A2.Thmtheorem1)\.

Part 2 \(lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|≤supT∈ℰf​\(T\)π∗​\(T,G\)\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\leq\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\_\{f\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\)\.Fix an enumeration𝒁=\{Zn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{Z\}\}=\\\{Z\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofT∖G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\.444IfT∖G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}is finite, we can fix a single\-step exhaustion that converges to a finite language\.Lethn=def\|Δ​Gn∖T\|h\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|andHn=∑i=1nhiH\_\{n\}=\\sum\_\{i=1\}^\{n\}h\_\{i\}\. We construct𝑻⋆=\{Tn⋆\}n=0∞∈ℰf​\(T\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}^\{\\star\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\_\{f\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}and distinguish two cases\.

Case 1\.limn→∞Hn=∞\\lim\_\{n\\to\\infty\}H\_\{n\}=\\infty\.

Define for eachn≥0n\\geq 0,

Tn⋆=def\(T∩Gn\)∪ZHn\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\)\\ \\cup Z\_\{H\_\{n\}\}\.\(49\)
Claim 1\.Tn⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}is anf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded exhaustion ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.

To start, noteTn⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}is finite andTn⋆⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Moreover,Tn⋆⊆Tn\+1⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\+1\}^\{\\star\}sinceGn⊆Gn\+1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\+1\}impliesT∩Gn⊆T∩Gn\+1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\+1\}, and sinceHn≤Hn\+1H\_\{n\}\\leq H\_\{n\+1\}holds\. Furthermore, by construction

\|Δ​Tn⋆\|=\|T∩Δ​Gn\|\+hn≤f​\(n\)\.\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\|=\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\+h\_\{n\}\\leq f\(n\)\.\(50\)Finally, becauselim supHn=∞\\limsup H\_\{n\}=\\infty, everyZkZ\_\{k\}appears inTn⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}for sufficiently largenn\. Also,\(T∩Gn\)↑\(T∩G\)\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\)\\uparrow\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\. HenceTn⋆↑T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}as desired\.

Claim 2\.Tn⋆∩Gn=T∩Gn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\.

Finally, for everynn,

Tn⋆∩Gn=\(T∩Gn\)∪\(ZHn∩Gn\)=T∩Gn,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\)\\cup\(Z\_\{H\_\{n\}\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\)=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\},\(51\)becauseZHn⊆T∖GZ\_\{H\_\{n\}\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}is disjoint fromGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\. We have that

π∗​\(𝑻⋆,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|Tn⋆∩Gn\|\|Gn\|=lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}^\{\\star\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(52\)
Case 2\.lim supnHn<∞\\limsup\_\{n\}H\_\{n\}<\\infty\.

First, we argue that the followinglim inf\\liminfis 1\.

lim infn→∞\|T∩Gn\|\|Gn\|=lim infn→∞\(1−Hn\|Gn\|\)=1\.\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\left\(1\-\\frac\{H\_\{n\}\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\right\)=1\.\(53\)This holds aslim supnHn<∞\\limsup\_\{n\}H\_\{n\}<\\inftyand𝑮\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}exhausts an infinite languageG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. Next, we show that we can construct an exhaustion that achieves the limit\. Choose an exploration setR⊂ℕ\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\subset\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}according to[Definition˜4\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem1)and writer​\(m\)=def\|R∩\{1,…,m\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\)\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\cap\\\{1,\\dots,m\\\}\|\.

Fix an enumeration𝒁=\{Zj\}j=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{Z\}\}=\\\{Z\_\{j\}\\\}\_\{j=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofT∖G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}withZ0=def∅Z\_\{0\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\emptyset\. Fix an enumeration𝒀=\{Yj\}j=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{Y\}\}=\\\{Y\_\{j\}\\\}\_\{j=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofT∩G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}such that

Y\|Gn∩T\|=Gn∩Tfor alln\.Y\_\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\qquad\\text\{for all $n$\.\}\(54\)Note that the enumerations are disjoint\.

Letmn=def\|Gn\|m\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\. We define the exhaustion𝑻⋆=\{Tn⋆\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}^\{\\star\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}by

Tn⋆=defYmn−r​\(mn\)∪Zr​\(mn\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}Y\_\{m\_\{n\}\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\}\\ \\cup\\ Z\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\}\.\(55\)Then\|Tn⋆\|=\(mn−r​\(mn\)\)\+r​\(mn\)=mn=\|Gn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\|=\(m\_\{n\}\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\)\+\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)=m\_\{n\}=\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|, and thus\|Δ​Tn⋆\|=mn−mn−1≤f​\(n\)\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\|=m\_\{n\}\-m\_\{n\-1\}\\leq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\)\. Furthermore,Tn⋆⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}for allnn\. Moreover, sincemnm\_\{n\},r​\(mn\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)andmn−r​\(mn\)m\_\{n\}\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)are nondecreasing, alsoTn⋆⊆Tn\+1⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\+1\}^\{\\star\}\. Finally,mn→∞m\_\{n\}\\to\\infty,mn−r​\(mn\)→∞m\_\{n\}\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\\to\\inftyandr​\(mn\)→∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\\to\\infty\(becauseR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}is infinite, but contains no consecutive integers\), we haveTn⋆↑T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. AsHnH\_\{n\}is bounded andr​\(mn\)→∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\\to\\infty, for large enoughnnwe have

\|Tn⋆∩Gn\|≥\|Ymn−r​\(mn\)\|=mn−r​\(mn\)\.\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\\ \\geq\\ \|Y\_\{\\,m\_\{n\}\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\}\|\\ =\\ m\_\{n\}\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\.\(56\)Dividing bymn=\|Gn\|m\_\{n\}=\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|and takinglim inf\\liminfyields

π∗​\(𝑻⋆,𝑮\)\\displaystyle\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}^\{\\star\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=lim infn→∞\|Tn⋆∩Gn\|\|Gn\|\\displaystyle=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\(57\)≥lim infn→∞\(1−r​\(mn\)mn\)=1,\\displaystyle\\geq\\ \\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\left\(1\-\\frac\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\}\{m\_\{n\}\}\\right\)=1,\(58\)usingr​\(mn\)/mn→0\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)/m\_\{n\}\\to 0\. Together with[Eq\.˜53](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A2.E53), this yieldsπ∗​\(𝑻⋆,𝑮\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\pi\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}^\{\\star\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\. ∎

## Appendix CRecall

### C\.1Exhaustion\-level recall

###### Example 3\(Recall need not exist\)\.

LetΣ=\{a\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}=\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}\\\}\. Define the target languageT=def\{an∣n∈ℕ\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}^\{n\}\\mid n\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\\\}with exhaustion𝐓\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}given by

Tn=def\{ai∣1≤i≤n\}\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}^\{i\}\\mid 1\\leq i\\leq n\\\}\.\(59\)Define the guess languageG⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}by alternating blocks: for eachm≥1m\\geq 1let

Im=def\(22​m−1,22​m\]I\_\{m\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\bigl\(2^\{2m\-1\},\\,2^\{2m\}\\bigr\]\(60\)and

Em=def\(22​m,22​m\+1\]\.E\_\{m\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\bigl\(2^\{2m\},\\,2^\{2m\+1\}\\bigr\]\.\(61\)Then include allan\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}^\{n\}withn∈Imn\\in I\_\{m\}and excludean\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}^\{n\}withn∈Emn\\in E\_\{m\}\. Formally,

G=def\{an∣n∈⋃m≥1Im\}\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}a\}\}^\{n\}\\mid n\\in\\bigcup\_\{m\\geq 1\}I\_\{m\}\\\}\.\(62\)Let𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}be the canonical exhaustion induced by𝐓\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},

Gn=defG∩Tn\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\.\(63\)ThenGn⊆Gn\+1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\+1\}andGn↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\.

SinceGn⊆Tn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}, we have

\|Tn∩Gn\|=\|Gn\|,\|Tn\|=n\.\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|,\\qquad\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|=n\.\(64\)Defining

rn=def\|Tn∩Gn\|\|Tn\|,r\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\},\(65\)we obtain

rn=\|Gn\|n\.r\_\{n\}=\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{n\}\.\(66\)
LetSm=def∑j=1m\|Ij\|=∑j=1m22​j−1=23​\(4m−1\)S\_\{m\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\sum\_\{j=1\}^\{m\}\|I\_\{j\}\|=\\sum\_\{j=1\}^\{m\}2^\{2j\-1\}=\\frac\{2\}\{3\}\\bigl\(4^\{m\}\-1\\bigr\)\. Then at the end of an included block we have\|G22​m\|=Sm\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{2^\{2m\}\}\|=S\_\{m\}, hence

r22​m=Sm22​m=23​\(4m−1\)4m=23​\(1−4−m\)→m→∞23\.r\_\{2^\{2m\}\}=\\frac\{S\_\{m\}\}\{2^\{2m\}\}=\\frac\{\\frac\{2\}\{3\}\(4^\{m\}\-1\)\}\{4^\{m\}\}=\\frac\{2\}\{3\}\\Bigl\(1\-4^\{\-m\}\\Bigr\)\\xrightarrow\[m\\to\\infty\]\{\}\\frac\{2\}\{3\}\.\(67\)At the end of the subsequent excluded block the numerator is stillSmS\_\{m\}, so

r22​m\+1=Sm22​m\+1=23​\(4m−1\)2⋅4m=13​\(1−4−m\)→m→∞13\.r\_\{2^\{2m\+1\}\}=\\frac\{S\_\{m\}\}\{2^\{2m\+1\}\}=\\frac\{\\frac\{2\}\{3\}\(4^\{m\}\-1\)\}\{2\\cdot 4^\{m\}\}=\\frac\{1\}\{3\}\\Bigl\(1\-4^\{\-m\}\\Bigr\)\\xrightarrow\[m\\to\\infty\]\{\}\\frac\{1\}\{3\}\.\(68\)Thusrnr\_\{n\}has two different limit points, and therefore, by the definitions oflim inf\\liminfandlim sup\\limsup,

ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)\\displaystyle\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=lim infn→∞rn≤13,\\displaystyle=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}r\_\{n\}\\leq\\frac\{1\}\{3\},\(69\)ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)\\displaystyle\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=lim supn→∞rn≥23,\\displaystyle=\\limsup\_\{n\\to\\infty\}r\_\{n\}\\geq\\frac\{2\}\{3\},\(70\)so the limit defining recall does not exist\.

### C\.2Coverage\-based recall

See[2\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.Thmtheorem2)

###### Proof\.

We prove the lemma in two parts\.

Part 1 \(supG∈ℰ​\(G\)ρ∗​\(T,G\)≤lim infn→∞\|Tn∩G\|\|Tn\|\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\leq\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\)\.Choose𝑮∈ℰ​\(G\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}arbitrarily\. BecauseGn⊆G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}for allnn, we have\|Tn∩Gn\|≤\|Tn∩G\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\\leq\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|for everynn\. Dividing by\|Tn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|and takinglim inf\\liminfyields

ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|Tn∩Gn\|\|Tn\|≤lim infn→∞\|Tn∩G\|\|Tn\|\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\leq\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(71\)Taking the supremum over𝑮∈ℰ​\(G\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}proves

sup𝑮∈ℰ​\(G\)ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)≤lim infn→∞\|Tn∩G\|\|Tn\|\.\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\}\\ \{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\\leq\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(72\)
Part 2 \(lim infn→∞\|Tn∩G\|\|Tn\|≤supG∈ℰ​\(G\)ρ∗​\(T,G\)\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\leq\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}\)\.

To show the reverse inequality, fix an exhaustion𝒀=\{Yn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{Y\}\}=\\\{Y\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}with𝒀↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{Y\}\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. Then, we define the following exhaustion𝑮⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}^\{\\star\}\}\}ofG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}: for eachn∈ℕn\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}, let

Gn⋆=def\(G∩Tn\)∪Yn\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\)\\ \\cup\\ Y\_\{n\}\.\(73\)Then eachGn⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}is finite,Gn⋆⊆Gn\+1⋆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\+1\}^\{\\star\}, andGn⋆↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}, so𝑮⋆∈ℰ​\(G\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}^\{\\star\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\. Moreover,

Gn⋆∩Tn\\displaystyle\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}=\(\(G∩Tn\)∪Yn\)∩Tn\\displaystyle=\\bigl\(\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\)\\cup Y\_\{n\}\\bigr\)\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\(74\)=\(G∩Tn\)∪\(Yn∩Tn\)\\displaystyle=\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\)\\cup\(Y\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\)\(75\)=G∩Tn,\\displaystyle=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\},\(76\)where the last equality usesYn∩Tn⊆G∩TnY\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\. Hence, for allnn,

\|Gn⋆∩Tn\|\|Tn\|=\|G∩Tn\|\|Tn\|\.\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(77\)Takinglim inf\\liminfyields

ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮⋆\)=lim infn→∞\|Gn⋆∩Tn\|\|Tn\|=lim infn→∞\|G∩Tn\|\|Tn\|,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}^\{\\star\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}^\{\\star\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\},\(78\)which proves the reverse inequality in[Eq\.˜12](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.E12)\. ∎

The same property can be proven for upper recall in an analogous way\.

###### Lemma C\.1\.

LetT⊆Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}be the target language and let𝐆=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be an exhaustion of the guess languageG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. Then,

sup𝑮∈ℰ​\(G\)ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=lim supn→∞\|Tn∩G\|\|Tn\|\.\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\limsup\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(79\)

Furthermore, we formulate a theorem analogous to[Theorem˜2\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.Thmtheorem1)for the recall\.

###### Theorem C\.2\.

Letf​\(n\):ℕ→ℕ\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\)\\colon\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\\to\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}be a function withlimN→∞∑n=1Nf​\(n\)=∞\\lim\_\{N\\to\\infty\}\\sum\_\{n=1\}^\{N\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\)=\\infty\. LetG⊆Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}be the guess language and let𝐓=\{Tn\}n=0∞∈ℰf​\(T\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\_\{f\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\)\}be anf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded exhaustion of the target languageT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Then,

sup𝑮∈ℰf​\(G\)ρ∗​\(𝑻,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|Tn∩G\|\|Tn\|\\sup\_\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{E\}\_\{f\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\rho\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\(80\)

###### Proof\.

Analogous to proof of[Theorem˜2\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.Thmtheorem1)\. ∎

## Appendix DTail precision

See[2\.4](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S2.Thmtheorem4)

###### Proof\.

For eachnn, recall the definition of the step\-wise tail precision:

tn=def\{1,if​\|Δ​Gn\|=0,\|T∩Δ​Gn\|\|Δ​Gn\|,otherwise\.t\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\begin\{cases\}1,&\\text\{if \}\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=0,\\\\\[2\.0pt\] \\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\},&\\text\{otherwise\.\}\\end\{cases\}\(81\)Assume first that at each step at most one new string is added, i\.e\.\|Δ​Gn\|≤1\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\\leq 1\(single\-step exhaustion\)\. Thentn∈\{0,1\}t\_\{n\}\\in\\\{0,1\\\}for allnn\. LetE=def\{n∈ℕ:tn=0\}E\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{n\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}:t\_\{n\}=0\\\}be the set of error steps\. IfEEis infinite, thentn=0t\_\{n\}=0occurs infinitely often and thus

lim infn→∞tn=0\.\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\}=0\.\(82\)IfEEis finite, letN0\>max⁡EN\_\{0\}\>\\max E\. Thentn=1t\_\{n\}=1for alln≥N0n\\geq N\_\{0\}, and hence

lim infn→∞tn=1\.\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\}=1\.\(83\)In either case,τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞tn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\}is reached after finitely many steps and equals either0or11\.

More generally, suppose there is a constantc≥1c\\geq 1such that\|Δ​Gn\|≤c\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\\leq cfor allnn\. Then for everynnwe have

tn∈Fc=def\{ij:i,j∈ℕ0,1≤j≤c,0≤i≤j\}\.t\_\{n\}\\in F\_\{c\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\Bigl\\\{\\frac\{i\}\{j\}\\colon i,j\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\_\{0\},1\\leq j\\leq c,0\\leq i\\leq j\\Bigr\\\}\.\(84\)Letℓ=deflim infn→∞tn\\ell\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\}\. Sincetnt\_\{n\}takes values in the finite setFcF\_\{c\}, there exists a minimum value among those that occur infinitely often; moreover this minimum equalsℓ\\ell\. In particular,ℓ∈Fc\\ell\\in F\_\{c\}andtn=ℓt\_\{n\}=\\elloccurs infinitely often\.

LetB=def\{x∈Fc:x<ℓ\}B\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{x\\in F\_\{c\}:x<\\ell\\\}\. Every valuex∈Bx\\in Bcan occur only finitely many times, otherwise we would havelim infn→∞tn≤x<ℓ\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\}\\leq x<\\ell, a contradiction\. Hence there existsN0N\_\{0\}such thattn∉Bt\_\{n\}\\notin Bfor alln≥N0n\\geq N\_\{0\}, i\.e\.tn≥ℓt\_\{n\}\\geq\\ellfor alln≥N0n\\geq N\_\{0\}\. Sincetn=ℓt\_\{n\}=\\elloccurs infinitely often, there is also somen≥N0n\\geq N\_\{0\}withtn=ℓt\_\{n\}=\\ell\. Therefore,

infm≥N0tm=ℓ,\\inf\_\{m\\geq N\_\{0\}\}t\_\{m\}=\\ell,\(85\)so the lower tail precisionτ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=ℓ\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\ellis attained from timen≥N0n\\geq N\_\{0\}onward\. ∎

See[3\.3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem3)

###### Proof\.

Recall the definition of the step\-wise tail precision:

tn=def\{1,\|Δ​Gn\|=0,\|T∩Δ​Gn\|\|Δ​Gn\|,\|Δ​Gn\|\>0\.t\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\begin\{cases\}1,&\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=0,\\\\\[5\.69054pt\] \\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\},&\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\>0\.\\end\{cases\}\(86\)By definition,τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞tn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\}\.

\(⇒\\Rightarrow\) If𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}is eventually valid, then there existsn⋆n^\{\\star\}such that for alln≥n⋆n\\geq n^\{\\star\},

𝒢​\(An,Gn−1\)⊆T\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\)\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.\(87\)Equivalently, for alln≥n⋆n\\geq n^\{\\star\}, every newly generated string lies inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, i\.e\.,Δ​Gn⊆T\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Thustn=1t\_\{n\}=1for alln≥n⋆n\\geq n^\{\\star\}, which means the tail\-precision sequence attains11from some finite time onward\.

\(⇐\\Leftarrow\) Conversely, supposeτ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1is attained in finite time\. This implies that there existsn⋆n^\{\\star\}such thattn=1t\_\{n\}=1for alln≥n⋆n\\geq n^\{\\star\}\. For any suchnn, if\|Δ​Gn\|\>0\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\>0then

\|Δ​Gn∩T\|\|Δ​Gn\|=1⟹Δ​Gn⊆T,\\frac\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\}\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=1\\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\(88\)and if\|Δ​Gn\|=0\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=0then there is nothing to show\. HenceΔ​Gn⊆T\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}for alln≥n⋆n\\geq n^\{\\star\}, i\.e\.,𝒢​\(An,Gn−1\)⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\)\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}for alln≥n⋆n\\geq n^\{\\star\}\. This is exactly eventual validity\. ∎

###### Lemma D\.1\(Tail precision11implies precision11\)\.

LetT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}be the target language and let𝐆=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be an exhaustion ofG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. Then

τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1⟹π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\\implies\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\.\(89\)

###### Proof\.

Forn≥1n\\geq 1, define

sn=def\|Δ​Gn\|,en=def\|Δ​Gn∖T\|\.s\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|,\\qquad e\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\.\(90\)
Ifsn=0s\_\{n\}=0, lettn=1t\_\{n\}=1, otherwise let

tn=def\|Δ​Gn∩T\|\|Δ​Gn\|=1−ensnandpn=def\|Gn∩T\|\|Gn\|=1−\|Gn∖T\|\|Gn\|\.t\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\frac\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\}\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=1\-\\frac\{e\_\{n\}\}\{s\_\{n\}\}\\qquad\\text\{and\}\\qquad p\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=1\-\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\.\(91\)
The assumptionτ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1meanslim infn→∞tn=1\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\}=1\. Since alwaystn≤1t\_\{n\}\\leq 1, this implieslimn→∞tn=1\\lim\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\}=1, hence

limn→∞ensn=0\.\\lim\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{e\_\{n\}\}\{s\_\{n\}\}=0\.\(92\)
Now letEn=def\|Gn∖T\|E\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|be the cumulative number of errors up to timenn\. We have

En=∑i=1neiand\|Gn\|=∑i=1nsi\.E\_\{n\}=\\sum\_\{i=1\}^\{n\}e\_\{i\}\\qquad\\text\{and\}\\qquad\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=\\sum\_\{i=1\}^\{n\}s\_\{i\}\.\(93\)Fixε\>0\\varepsilon\>0\. Sincelimn→∞en/sn=0\\lim\_\{n\\to\\infty\}e\_\{n\}/s\_\{n\}=0, there existsNNsuch thaten≤ε​sne\_\{n\}\\leq\\varepsilon s\_\{n\}for alln≥Nn\\geq N\. Then for anyn≥Nn\\geq N,

En=∑i=1N−1ei\+∑i=Nnei≤∑i=1N−1ei\+ε​∑i=Nnsi≤∑i=1N−1ei\+ε​\|Gn\|\.E\_\{n\}=\\sum\_\{i=1\}^\{N\-1\}e\_\{i\}\+\\sum\_\{i=N\}^\{n\}e\_\{i\}\\leq\\sum\_\{i=1\}^\{N\-1\}e\_\{i\}\+\\varepsilon\\sum\_\{i=N\}^\{n\}s\_\{i\}\\leq\\sum\_\{i=1\}^\{N\-1\}e\_\{i\}\+\\varepsilon\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\.\(94\)Dividing by\|Gn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|gives

En\|Gn\|≤∑i=1N−1ei\|Gn\|\+ε\.\\frac\{E\_\{n\}\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\leq\\frac\{\\sum\_\{i=1\}^\{N\-1\}e\_\{i\}\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\+\\varepsilon\.\(95\)SinceGn↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}andG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}is an infinite set, the first term tends to0, solim supn→∞En\|Gn\|≤ε\\limsup\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{E\_\{n\}\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\leq\\varepsilon\. Asε\>0\\varepsilon\>0can be chosen arbitrarily, we concludelimn→∞En\|Gn\|=0\\lim\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{E\_\{n\}\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=0, and therefore

limn→∞pn=limn→∞1−En\|Gn\|→1\.\\lim\_\{n\\to\\infty\}p\_\{n\}=\\lim\_\{n\\to\\infty\}1\-\\frac\{E\_\{n\}\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\to 1\.\(96\)Henceπ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞pn=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}p\_\{n\}=1\. ∎

## Appendix EGeneration without novelty

### E\.1Generation without novelty but perfect tail precision

###### Theorem E\.1\.

Let𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be a countable collection of languages and letT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be the target language\. Fix an enumeration𝐓=\{Tn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. There exists a generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}such that, for anyf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded adversarial exhaustion𝐀=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}andρ^∗​\(𝐓,A\)≥α\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\\geq\\alpha, the generated exhaustion𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}isf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded and satisfies:

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥α,τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1,π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq\\alpha,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\.\(97\)Moreover, forcc\-step exhaustions the recall guarantee is tight in an adversarial sense\.

###### Proof\.

Define𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}by simply copying the adversary:

𝒢​\(An,Gn−1\)=defΔ​Anfor all​n≥0\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\)\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\qquad\\text\{for all \}n\\geq 0\.\(98\)Hence,Δ​Gn=Δ​An\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}, andGn=An\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\. Then𝑮\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}isf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded whenever𝑨\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}is\.

Precision and tail precision\.SinceGn=An⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}for allnn, we have

π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|Gn∩T\|\|Gn\|=lim infn→∞\|Gn\|\|Gn\|=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=1\.\(99\)The step\-wise tail precisiontn=1t\_\{n\}=1wheneverΔ​Gn=∅\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\\emptyset\.

Furthermore,Δ​Gn=Δ​An⊆T\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, so

τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|T∩Δ​Gn\|\|Δ​Gn\|=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\cap\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=1\.\(100\)
Recall\.BecauseGn=An\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}for allnn,

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)≥α\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\\geq\\alpha\.\(101\)
Tightness of the recall bound\.We construct a case in which the recall cannot exceedα\\alpha\.

Assumef\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}enforces acc\-step exhaustion\. FixT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}and a strict sublanguageA⊂T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subset\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}withρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)=α<1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}=\\alpha<1, and assume alsoA∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}\.

Consider acc\-step exhaustion ofA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\. Any generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}that is required to satisfyτ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1for*every*possible true language in𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}must in particular satisfy it when the true language isA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\. Recall that for eachnn, we have

tn=\{1,if​\|Δ​Gn\|=0,\|A∩Δ​Gn\|\|Δ​Gn\|,otherwise\.t\_\{n\}=\\begin\{cases\}1,&\\text\{if \}\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=0,\\\\\[2\.0pt\] \\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\},&\\text\{otherwise\.\}\\end\{cases\}\(102\)Since\|Δ​Gn\|≤c\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\\leq c, eachtnt\_\{n\}belongs to the finite set

Fc=def\{ij:i,j∈ℕ0,1≤j≤c,0≤i≤j\}\.F\_\{c\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\Bigl\\\{\\frac\{i\}\{j\}\\colon i,j\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\_\{0\},1\\leq j\\leq c,0\\leq i\\leq j\\Bigr\\\}\.\(103\)Iflim infn→∞tn=1\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}t\_\{n\}=1, then we must havetn=1t\_\{n\}=1for all sufficiently largennbecauseFcF\_\{c\}is finite: otherwise some value<1<1would occur infinitely often, forcing thelim inf\\liminfto be≤max⁡\(Fc∖\{1\}\)<1\\leq\\max\(F\_\{c\}\\setminus\\\{1\\\}\)<1\. Hence, when the true language isA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, the generator can output strings outsideA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}only finitely many times\.

Now note that the adversary exhaustion can be identical whether the true language isA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}orT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. It follows that for the instance where the target language isT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, the generator must also eventually restrict toA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, as it cannot possibly know if the true language isT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}orA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\. Consequently it cannot guarantee asymptotic recall exceeding that ofA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}insideT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, i\.e\., it cannot guaranteeρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)\>α\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\>\\alphain general\. ∎

### E\.2Generation without novelty and without perfect tail precision

Algorithm 1Language generation in the limit without novelty or perfect tail precision\.Input:adversarial exhaustion\{An\}n=0∞\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, enumeration𝑬\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{E\}\}ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}, infinite exploration setR⊂ℕ\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\subset\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\.Ensures:increasing exhaustion𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}\.1:

G0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

G1←A1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{1\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{1\},

j←1j\\leftarrow 1
2:

rnext←min⁡\(R\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}\\leftarrow\\min\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\)
3:for

n=1,2,3,…n=1,2,3,\\dotsdo

4:if

\|Gn\|≥rnext​Δ​An\+1≠∅\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\\geq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next \}\}\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\+1\}\\neq\\emptysetthen

5:

Gn\+1←Gn∪Δ​Ej\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\+1\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cup\\Delta E\_\{j\}⊳\\trianglerightexploration round

6:

j←j\+1j\\leftarrow j\+1
7:

rnext←min⁡\{r∈R:r\>rnext\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}\\leftarrow\\min\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}:\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\>\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}\\\}
8:else

9:

Gn\+1←Gn∪Δ​An\+1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\+1\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cup\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\+1\}⊳\\trianglerightsafe round

10:endif

11:endfor

See[4\.3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem3)

###### Proof\.

Since novelty is not required, the generator may repeat the adversary’s outputs\. We will construct an algorithm that mimics the adversary’s strings and occasionally introduces new, potentially incorrect strings at a vanishing rate\. We call these insertions exploration rounds\. Fix an arbitrary enumeration𝑬=\{En\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{E\}\}=\\\{E\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\. Choose an exploration setR⊂ℕ\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\subset\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}according to[Definition˜4\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem1), and letr​\(m\)=def\|R∩\{1,…,m\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\)\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\cap\\\{1,\\dots,m\\\}\|\. We useR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}to trigger exploration rounds whenever\|Gn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|reaches anr∈R\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\. We construct anf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}iteratively as described in[Algorithm˜1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg1)\. The exhaustion𝑮\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}isf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded because, on a safe round, it adds exactly the strings inΔ​An\+1\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\+1\}, while an exploration round adds only one string and is taken only ifΔ​An\+1≠∅\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\+1\}\\neq\\emptyset\. In the latter case,f​\(n\+1\)≥1\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\+1\)\\geq 1, and hence the exploration output also respects the bound\.

By construction,Gn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}is increasing\. Moreover, we ensure that exploration happens only whenever\|Gn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|reaches the next value inR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\. This will ensure that forGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}with\|Gn\|=mn\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=m\_\{n\}, the number of explorative strings is at mostr​\(mn\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\.

#### Recall\.

EveryΔ​En\\Delta E\_\{n\}gets added eventually, henceGn↑Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}and

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=lim infn→∞\|Tn∩G\|\|Tn\|=lim infn→∞\|Tn\|\|Tn\|=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}=1\.\(104\)

#### Precision\.

For eachGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}with\|Gn\|=mn\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=m\_\{n\}the number of outputs from explorations \(and hence possible hallucinations\) is at mostr​\(mn\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\); all other outputs are parroted adversary elements and thus lie inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}becauseA⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Hence

\|Gn∩T\|≥mn−r​\(mn\)\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\\geq m\_\{n\}\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\(105\)and therefore

π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=lim infn→∞\|Gn∩T\|\|Gn\|\\displaystyle\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\(106\)≥lim infn→∞\(1−r​\(mn\)mn\)=1\.\\displaystyle\\geq\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\left\(1\-\\frac\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\_\{n\}\)\}\{m\_\{n\}\}\\right\)=1\.\(107\)∎

## Appendix FPods algorithm

In this section, we give[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)’s \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\) algorithm and describe its main ideas\. We fix a countable collection of languages𝒯⊆𝒫​\(Σ∗\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}\\subseteq\\mathcal\{P\}\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\)together with \(i\) a global order on languages in𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}, yielding an ordered sequence\(Si′\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}and \(ii\) an enumeration ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}that induces a total order≺\\prec\. For a string𝒙∈T\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}we define its successor bysuccT​\(𝒙\)\\mathrm\{succ\}\_\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)in\(T,≺\)\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\\prec\)\.555Note that≺\\preccan be applied to any languageS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}inΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}, asS⊆Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\.

We recall the two main technical primitives fromKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\): the*identified intersection*procedure and the*pods*construction\.

#### Consistency and intersection chains\.

LetT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be the target language\. An adversary reveals an exhaustion𝑨\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}\. Note that inKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)this exhaustion is single\-step\-bounded\. However, we write[Algorithm˜2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg2)in a way such that it can also be run with akk\-batched adversary, a setting that we analyze in[Section˜G\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.SS1)\.

###### Definition F\.1\.

Let𝐀=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be an adversarial exhaustion andS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}an arbitrary language\. We callS\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}consistentwith𝐀\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}up to timestepnnifAn⊆S\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\.

###### Definition F\.2\.

Let the consistent languages at timennbe listed in the global order asS1\(n\),S2\(n\),S3\(n\),…\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{2\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{3\},\\dots, where\(Si\(n\)\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}is obtained by scanningS1,S2,…\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{2\},\\dotsand keeping exactly those that containAn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\. If only finitely many, saykk, consistent languages remain at timenn, we pad the sequence by repeating the last language, namely

Sl\(n\)=Sk\(n\),l≥k\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{l\}^\{\(n\)\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}\_\{k\}^\{\(n\)\},\\qquad l\\geq k\(108\)
We define the descendingchain of intersectionsat timennby

ℐi\(n\)=def⋂j≤iSj\(n\),Cn=defℐ1\(n\)⊇ℐ2\(n\)⊇ℐ3\(n\)⊇⋯\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\bigcap\_\{j\\leq i\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{j\},\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{1\}\\supseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{2\}\\supseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{3\}\\supseteq\\cdots\.\(109\)

Note thatCn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}is always an infinite chain\(Kleinberg and Wei,[2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Eq\. 3\)\. See also[Algorithm˜3](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg3)\.

#### Identified intersection\.

[Algorithm˜4](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg4)describes how to find the best guessℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}of the target language by intersecting the remaining consistent hypotheses\.ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}is calledidentified intersection\. The algorithm chooses an indexi​\(n\)∈ℕi\(n\)\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}such that the outputℐ\(n\)=defℐi​\(n\)\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\(n\)\}is an infinite set \(except in finitely many cases\) and moves in a controlled way over time asnnincreases\. Concretely, if the descending chain of intersections remains the same between roundsnnandn\+1n\+1, the algorithm either keepsi​\(n\+1\)=i​\(n\)i\(n\+1\)=i\(n\)or increases it by one \(moving one step deeper in the intersection chain\) provided the next intersection is still infinite\. If the set of consistent hypotheses changes, the algorithm resetsi​\(n\+1\)i\(n\+1\)to the deepest level at which the old and new intersection chains still agree on an infinite set\.

We use the following terminology matchingKleinberg and Wei,[2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\. We say thatℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}isvalidifℐ\(n\)⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}; andfullifA⊆ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\.

Kleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Lem\. 2\.5\)establish the following structural properties ofℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}: there exists a finite timeN0N\_\{0\}such that for alln≥N0n\\geq N\_\{0\},

1. 1\.\(*eventual validity*\)ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}is valid;
2. 2\.\(*eventual comparability*\) eitherℐ\(n\)⊂ℐ\(n\+1\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\subset\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\+1\)\}orℐ\(n\+1\)⊂ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\+1\)\}\\subset\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\};
3. 3\.\(*full infinitely many times*\) the event*ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}is full*occurs infinitely often\.

Intuitively,ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}is the algorithm’s current safe proxy forT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Onceℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}is valid, every string in it lies inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, so outputting fromℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}preserves validity\. Eventual comparability means that after finitely many steps the sequence evolves keeping some inclusion relation between consecutive identified intersections, which the later analysis repeatedly exploits to control how the identified intersection changes over time\. Finally, the fact thatℐn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{n\}is full infinitely often guarantees that the process repeatedly returns to an intersection that containsA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, a property which can be exploited to support high recall\.

#### Pods generator algorithm\.

[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)introduce a generating procedure \(see[Algorithm˜2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg2)\) that achieves the properties in[Theorem˜3\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem5)\. In each timestepnnit decides on anaggressive setℐ~\(n\)\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\(see[Algorithm˜5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg5), as defined inKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Sec\. 3\.2\)\), which consists of strings that could be part ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, though including them may risk overshooting\. Intuitively,ℐ~\(n\)\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}is either the current identified intersectionℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}or a controlled fallback superset from earlier rounds\. Furthermore, in each round, apodPn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}is determined\. A podPn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}is a set of strings that have priority to be output\. The pod sizes are fixed as a growing sequence, for example\(sn\)n≥1\(s\_\{n\}\)\_\{n\\geq 1\}withsn=ns\_\{n\}=n\. The algorithm maintains a setUn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}of strings that are*used*, meaning they have been revealed by the adversary, already output, or already placed into previous pods:

Un=defAn∪Gn−1∪⋃ν<nPν\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\\bigcup\_\{\\nu<n\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{\\nu\}\.\(110\)ThepodPn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}is formed by thesns\_\{n\}≺\\prec\-smallest elements ofℐ~\(n\)∖Un\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\. Furthermore, the algorithm maintains apod pool𝒫n\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}of available pod elements waiting to be output\. The algorithm outputs the smallest element in𝒫n∖\(An∪Gn−1\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\)\. By construction, the generated exhaustion𝑮\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}satisfies the novelty constraint\.

Algorithm 2Pods algorithm for language generation in the limit \(afterKleinberg and Wei,[2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\)\.UpdateChaintakes the adversary’s input and a sequence of languages and returns an updated sequence of languages and a chain of intersections of consistent languages;IdIntersecttakes the timestep and a level index, two intersection chains and an identified intersection and returns the next level index and the next identified intersection;AggrSettakes two identified intersections and two intersection chains and returns an aggressive set, i\.e\., a superset of the current identified intersection\.Input:adversarial exhaustion\{An\}n=0∞\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, pod size sequence\(sn\)n≥1\(s\_\{n\}\)\_\{n\\geq 1\}, ordered sequence\(Si′\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}of languages in𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}Ensures:single\-step exhaustion𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}\.1:

G0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

U0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset\{unavailable strings\},

𝒫0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset\{pod pool\},

\(Si\(0\)\)i≥1←\(Si′\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(0\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\\leftarrow\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\{consistent languages\},

k0←1k\_\{0\}\\leftarrow 1,

ℐ\(0\)←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(0\)\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

C0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset
2:for

n=1,2,3,…n=1,2,3,\\dotsdo

3:Observe

An\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}
4:

\(\(Si\(n\)\)i≥1,Cn\)←UpdateChain​\(Δ​An,\(Si\(n−1\)\)i≥1\)\\bigl\(\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\\bigr\)\\leftarrow\\textsc\{UpdateChain\}\\bigl\(\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\},\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\\bigr\)
5:

\(ℐ\(n\),kn\)←\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\},k\_\{n\}\)\\leftarrowIdIntersect\(n,kn−1,ℐ\(n−1\),Cn−1,Cn\)\(n,k\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\)

6:

ℐ~\(n\)←\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\leftarrowAggrSet\(n,ℐ\(n−1\),ℐ\(n\),Cn−1,Cn\)\(n,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\)

7:

Un←Un−1∪An\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\.

8:

Pn←\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrowthe

sns\_\{n\}≺\\prec\-smallest elements of

ℐ~\(n\)∖Un\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\.

9:

Un←Un∪Pn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}
10:

𝒫n←𝒫n−1∪Pn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}\.

11:

Gn←Gn−1∪min≺⁡\(𝒫n∖\(An∪Gn−1\)\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\\min\_\{\\prec\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\)\)\.

12:

Un←Un∪Gn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\.

13:endfor

Algorithm 3UpdateChain\(Δ​An,\(Si\(n−1\)\)i≥1\)\(\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\},\\,\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\),Input:current adversarial incrementΔ​A=An∖An−1\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\-1\}, previous consistent list\(Si\(n−1\)\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}Ensures:updated consistent list\(Si\(n\)\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}, intersection chainCn=\(ℐi\(n\)\)i≥1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}=\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}1:

t←0t\\leftarrow 0
2:for

i=1,2,3,…i=1,2,3,\\dotsdo

3:if

Δ​An⊆Si\(n−1\)\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{i\}then

4:

t←t\+1t\\leftarrow t\+1
5:

St\(n\)←Si\(n−1\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{t\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{i\}
6:if

t=1t=1then

7:

ℐ1\(n\)←S1\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{1\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{1\}
8:else

9:

ℐt\(n\)←ℐt−1\(n\)∩St\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{t\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{t\-1\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{t\}
10:endif

11:endif

12:endfor

13:return

\(\(Si\(n\)\)i≥1,\(ℐi\(n\)\)i≥1\)\\bigl\(\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\},\\,\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\\bigr\)

Algorithm 4IdIntersect\(n,kn−1,ℐ\(n−1\),Cn−1,Cn\)\(n,k\_\{n\-1\},\\,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\},\\,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\},\\,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\)Input:timestepnn, identified intersectionℐ\(n−1\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}, level indexkn−1k\_\{n\-1\}, descending chainsCn−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\}andCn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}Ensures:updated identified intersectionℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}and updated level indexknk\_\{n\}\.1:if

n=1n=1then

2:return

\(ℐ1\(1\),1\)\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(1\)\}\_\{1\},\\,1\)
3:endif

4:

k←kn−1k\\leftarrow k\_\{n\-1\}
5:if

Cn−1=Cn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}then

6:if

\|ℐk\+1\(n−1\)\|=∞\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{k\+1\}\|=\\inftythen

7:return

\(ℐ\(n\)←ℐk\+1\(n−1\),kn←k\+1\)\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{k\+1\},\\,k\_\{n\}\\leftarrow k\+1\)\{move down one level\}

8:else

9:return

\(ℐ\(n\)←ℐk\(n−1\),kn←k\)\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{k\},\\,k\_\{n\}\\leftarrow k\)\{stay if next set becomes finite\}

10:endif

11:else

12:

k⋆←0k^\{\\star\}\\leftarrow 0
13:for

j=1,2,3,…j=1,2,3,\\dotsdo

14:if

ℐj\(n−1\)=ℐj\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{j\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{j\}\|ℐj\(n−1\)\|=∞\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{j\}\|=\\inftythen

15:

k⋆←jk^\{\\star\}\\leftarrow j
16:else

17:break

18:endif

19:endfor

20:if

k⋆≥1k^\{\\star\}\\geq 1then

21:return

\(ℐ\(n\)←ℐk⋆\(n−1\),kn←k⋆\)\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{k^\{\\star\}\},\\,k\_\{n\}\\leftarrow k^\{\\star\}\)\{largest common infinite prefix\}

22:else

23:return

\(ℐ\(n\)←ℐ1\(n\),kn←1\)\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{1\},\\,k\_\{n\}\\leftarrow 1\)\{no common infinite prefix\}

24:endif

25:endif

Algorithm 5AggrSet\(n,ℐ\(n−1\),ℐ\(n\),Cn−1,Cn\)\(n,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\)Input:roundnn, identified intersectionℐ\(n−1\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}andℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}, descending chainsCn−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\}andCn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}Ensures:Aggressive setℐ~\(n\)\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\.1:if

n=1n=1then

2:return

ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}
3:endif

4:if

ℐ\(n\)=ℐ\(n−1\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}then

5:return

ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\{no fallback\}

6:elseif

ℐ\(n\)⊊ℐ\(n−1\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\subsetneq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}then

7:return

ℐ\(n−1\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\{aggressively guess the previous larger set\}

8:elseif

ℐ\(n\)⊋ℐ\(n−1\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\supsetneq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}then

9:return

ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\{aggressively guess the new larger set\}

10:else

11:\{incomparable case: search for a common predecessor in both chains\}

12:

𝒮n−1←\{J∈Cn−1:J⊇ℐ\(n−1\)\}\\mathcal\{S\}\_\{n\-1\}\\leftarrow\\\{J\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\}\\colon J\\supseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\\\}
13:

𝒮n←\{J∈Cn:J⊇ℐ\(n\)\}\\mathcal\{S\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\\\{J\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}:J\\supseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\\}
14:

𝒮←𝒮n−1∩𝒮n\\mathcal\{S\}\\leftarrow\\mathcal\{S\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cap\\mathcal\{S\}\_\{n\}
15:if

𝒮=∅\\mathcal\{S\}=\\emptysetthen

16:return

ℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\{no fallback possible\}

17:else

18:returna

⊆\\subseteq\-minimal element of

𝒮\\mathcal\{S\}
19:endif

20:endif

## Appendix GRecall bounds in a batched adversary setting

### G\.1Lower recall bound

See[4\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem5)

###### Proof\.

We use[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)’s \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\) algorithm as described in[Algorithm˜2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg2)\. By construction,𝑮\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}satisfies the novelty constraint, as all outputs come from pod pools𝒫n\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}, that contain only unseen strings at stepnn\. The major difference to the original setting is that in each timestep the adversary revealskkstrings, and hence we choose the consistent languages based onkkstrings instead of just one\. The procedure of computing the intersections remains the same\. Note that the properties of eventual validity, eventual comparability, and being full infinitely often transfer to this setting\. The proof is analogous to the proof ofKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Lemma 2\.5\)\. The procedure of choosing the aggressive sets and pods remains also the same\. Hence, our proof follows the structure ofKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Thm\. 3\.5\)closely and differs only in certain counting steps\.

#### Tail precision and precision\.

After finitely many timestepsNNthe identified intersectionℐ\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\}and the aggressive setℐ~\(n\)\\smash\{\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}remain valid \(seeKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Lemma 2\.5\)and[Algorithm˜5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg5)\)\. Hence, up to that point only finitely many wrong strings can be added to𝒫N\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{N\}and afterwards only strings fromT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}are added\. This immediately implies

tn=\|Δ​Gn∩T\|\|Δ​Gn\|=1n≥Nt\_\{n\}=\\frac\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\}\{\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=1\\qquad n\\geq N\(111\)and thusτ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1andπ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1by[Lemma˜D\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A4.Thmtheorem1)\.

#### Recall\.

Denote by𝒫=⋃n≥1Pn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}=\\bigcup\_\{n\\geq 1\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}the set of all strings that ever appear in a pod\. We define a partition into a good and bad set as inKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Thm\. 3\.5\):

Bg:=\{𝒙∈A∖\(𝒫∪G\):∀𝒚∈Pν​\(𝒙\)−1,𝒚⪯succT​\(𝒙\)\},\\displaystyle B\_\{g\}:=\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\setminus\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\):\\ \\forall\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\-1\},\\ \{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\\preceq\\mathrm\{succ\}\_\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\\\},\(112\)Bb:=\(A∖\(𝒫∪G\)\)∖Bg,\\displaystyle B\_\{b\}:=\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\setminus\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\)\\setminus B\_\{g\},\(113\)whereν​\(𝒙\)\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)is the first round in which𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}appears amongAν​\(𝒙\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\}\.

LetN1N\_\{1\}be the time from which on all identified intersections are valid\. We letNNbe sufficiently large such that atNNwe have already observed a full intersection twice sinceN1N\_\{1\}\.

#### BoundingBbB\_\{b\}andBgB\_\{g\}\.

We fix anss\. By Lemma[G\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.Thmtheorem1), there exists a mapρ\\rhofrom bad strings to pod indices such thatPρ​\(𝒙\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{\\rho\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\}contains at leastsselements, all≺𝒙\\prec\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}, and each index has at mostkkpreimages\. This implies

\|Bb∩Tn\|≤k​\(1s​\|𝒫∩Tn\|\+𝒪​\(N\)\+𝒪​\(s\)\)\.\|B\_\{b\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\\ \\leq k\\big\(\\frac\{1\}\{s\}\\,\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\\ \+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(N\)\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(s\)\\big\)\.\(114\)
Furthermore, we can bound\|Bg∩Tn\|\|B\_\{g\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|by mapping each𝒙∈Bg\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in B\_\{g\}to the pod output at timeν​\(𝒙\)−1\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\-1\. Hence, at mostkkstrings get mapped to the same pod\. For a string𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}withν​\(𝒙\)≥s\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\\geq s, each previous pod contains at leastsselements, which are≺𝒙\\prec\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}by definition ofBgB\_\{g\}\. Hence,

\|Bg∩Tn\|≤k​\(1s​\|𝒫∩Tn\|\+𝒪​\(N\)\+𝒪​\(s\)\)\|B\_\{g\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\\leq k\\big\(\\frac\{1\}\{s\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(N\)\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(s\)\\big\)\(115\)

#### Charging pod elements to outputs\.

The only further major difference appears in[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)’s \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\) charging argument \(their Eq\. \(14\)\)\. In ourkk\-batched setting, at mostkknew adversary elements can enter the pool per round, hence

\|\(𝒫∩\(A∖G\)\)∩Tn\|≤k​\|𝒫∩G∩Tn\|=k​\|G∩Tn\|,\|\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\)\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\\ \\leq\\ k\\,\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|=k\\,\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|,\(116\)asG⊆𝒫\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\.

#### Combining bounds\.

Every𝒙∈A\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}lies in exactly one of

\(𝒫∩\(A∖G\)\),\(𝒫∩G\)∩A,Bb,Bg\.\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\),\\qquad\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\},\\qquad B\_\{b\},\\qquad B\_\{g\}\.\(117\)Intersecting withTn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}and taking cardinalities yields

\|A∩Tn\|\\displaystyle\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|=\|\(A∩G\)∩Tn\|\+\|\(𝒫∩\(A∖G\)\)∩Tn\|\+\|Bb∩Tn\|\+\|Bg∩Tn\|\.\\displaystyle=\|\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\+\|\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\)\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\+\|B\_\{b\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\+\|B\_\{g\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\.The first term is at most\|G∩Tn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\. The second term is bounded byk​\|G∩Tn\|k\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|by[Eq\.˜116](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.E116)\. The last two terms are bounded using[Eq\.˜114](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.E114)and[Eq\.˜115](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.E115)\. Altogether,

\|A∩Tn\|≤\(k\+1\)​\|G∩Tn\|\+2​ks​\|𝒫∩Tn\|\+𝒪​\(k​N\)\+𝒪​\(k​s\)\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\\ \\leq\\ \(k\+1\)\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\+\\frac\{2k\}\{s\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(kN\)\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(ks\)\(118\)

#### Bounding pool mass by outputs\.

We next bound\|𝒫∩Tn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|in terms of\|G∩Tn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\. Using thatG⊆𝒫\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\(the algorithm always outputs from the pool\), we may decompose

𝒫∩Tn⊆\(G∩Tn\)∪\(\(𝒫∩\(A∖G\)\)∩Tn\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\subseteq\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\)\\ \\cup\\ \(\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\)\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\)\.\(119\)Taking cardinalities and applying[Eq\.˜116](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.E116)gives

\|𝒫∩Tn\|≤\|G∩Tn\|\+\|\(𝒫∩\(A∖G\)\)∩Tn\|≤\(k\+1\)​\|G∩Tn\|\.\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\\ \\leq\\ \|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\+\|\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cap\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\)\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\\ \\leq\\ \(k\+1\)\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\.\(120\)
Substituting[Eq\.˜120](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.E120)into[Eq\.˜118](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.E118)yields

\|A∩Tn\|≤\(\(k\+1\)\+2​k​\(k\+1\)s\)​\|G∩Tn\|\+𝒪​\(k​N\+k​s\)\.\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\\ \\leq\\ \\Bigl\(\(k\+1\)\+\\frac\{2k\(k\+1\)\}\{s\}\\Bigr\)\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(kN\+ks\)\.\(121\)Dividing bynnand takinglim infn→∞\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}, we obtain

lim infn→∞\|A∩Tn\|n≤\(\(k\+1\)\+2​k​\(k\+1\)s\)​lim infn→∞\|G∩Tn\|n\.\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{n\}\\leq\\ \\Bigl\(\(k\+1\)\+\\frac\{2k\(k\+1\)\}\{s\}\\Bigr\)\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{n\}\.\(122\)
Lettings→∞s\\to\\inftygives

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥1k\+1​ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq\\frac\{1\}\{k\+1\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\(123\)which proves the claim\. ∎

###### Lemma G\.1\(Batched bad\-string pod map\)\.

Fixs∈ℕs\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}and consider the pods generator algorithm \(Algorithm[2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg2)\) in thekk\-batched setting\. There exists a finite timeNNand a map

ρ:\{𝒙∈Bb:ν​\(𝒙\)\>N\}→ℕ\\rho:\\ \\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in B\_\{b\}:\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\>N\\\}\\to\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\(124\)such that for every𝐱∈Bb\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in B\_\{b\}withν​\(𝐱\)\>N\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\>N:

1. 1\.all elements ofPρ​\(𝒙\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{\\rho\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\}are≺𝒙\\prec\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}and\|Pρ​\(𝒙\)\|≥s\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{\\rho\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\}\|\\geq s;
2. 2\.\(*bounded multiplicity*\) each indexn′∈ℕn^\{\\prime\}\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}has at mostkkpreimages:\|ρ−1​\(n′\)\|≤k\|\\rho^\{\-1\}\(n^\{\\prime\}\)\|\\leq k\.

###### Proof\.

The proof followsKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Lem\. 3\.6\)\. LetN1N\_\{1\}be the time from which on all identified intersections are valid\. We letNNbe sufficiently large such that atNNwe have already observed a full intersection twice sinceN1N\_\{1\}\. Furthermore, we assumen≥sn\\geq sfor the rest of the proof\. Fix𝒙∈Bb\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in B\_\{b\}with appearance timeν​\(𝒙\)\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\), yielding𝒙∈ℐ\(ν​\(𝒙\)\)\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\)\}\.𝒙∈Bb\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in B\_\{b\}means that𝒙∉𝒫∪G\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\notin\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}and hence in no previous pod, however, a pod element beyondsuccT​\(𝒙\)\\mathrm\{succ\}\_\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)is inPν​\(𝒙\)−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\-1\}\. Hence,𝒙∉ℐ\(ν​\(𝒙\)−1\)\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\notin\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\-1\)\}andℐ\(ν​\(𝒙\)−1\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\-1\)\}is inconsistent at roundν​\(𝒙\)\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)and the identified intersection must make an upward move to a*superset*within the prior chain, exactly as inKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Lem\. 3\.6\)\. Consequently, there exists a timen<ν​\(𝒙\)n<\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)such that the identified intersections at timesnnandν​\(𝒙\)\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)coincide, and we defineρ​\(𝒙\)≔n\\rho\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\\coloneqq n\. If there are multiple previous times at which the identified intersections coincide with the one atν​\(𝒙\)\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\), we choose the largest such indexnn\.

Consider the podPn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}created at timenn\. By construction,Pn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}contains thesns\_\{n\}smallest unused strings in the aggressive set, which is a superset of the corresponding identified intersection\. Because𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}first appears at timeν​\(𝒙\)\\nu\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)and𝒙∉𝒫∪G\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\notin\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}, it was unused at timenn; however, it appeared in the identified intersection and the aggressive set at that time\. Thus every element added toPn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}must be≺𝒙\\prec\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}, and sincen≥sn\\geq sfor all sufficiently large times, we also have\|Pn\|=sn≥s\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}\|=s\_\{n\}\\geq s\.

Finally, the only difference fromKleinberg and Wei \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8), Lem\. 3\.6\)is thatρ\\rhois no longer injective: in thekk\-batched model, at mostkknew strings can arrive in a single round, possibly triggering one upward move together\. Each string𝒙∈Bb\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in B\_\{b\}from that round yields the sameρ​\(𝒙\)\\rho\(\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\)\. However, strings arriving in later rounds will be mapped to another index\. Hence,\|ρ−1​\(n\)\|≤k\|\\rho^\{\-1\}\(n\)\|\\leq kfor allnn\. ∎

### G\.2Upper recall bound

See[4\.6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem6)

###### Proof\.

Assume any countable collection of languages𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}\. Assume a single\-step novel generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}that satisfiesτ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\. Let𝑻=\{Tn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}be an enumeration ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.

#### Full exhaustion\.

Assume first that the adversary fully revealsT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, i\.e\.,An↑T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}and henceρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}=1\. We define an adversary exhaustion that forces

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≤1k\+1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\leq\\frac\{1\}\{k\+1\}\.\(125\)
LetR=def\{2m:m∈ℕ0\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\\\{2^\{m\}:m\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\_\{0\}\\\}be the set of so\-called repetition steps and definer​\(n\)=def\|R∩\{1,…,n\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(n\)\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\cap\\\{1,\\dots,n\\\}\|\. At each timestepn∈ℕn\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}, the adversary reveals a set of at mostkknew strings as follows\. Ifn∉Rn\\notin\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}, it reveals thekksmallest strings inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\(with respect to the ordering induced by the enumeration𝑻\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}\) that have not yet been used by either player, or more formally, it outputs the unused strings fromTin\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{i\_\{n\}\}, whereini\_\{n\}is the smallest index such that\|Tin∖\(An−1∪Gn−1\)\|=k\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{i\_\{n\}\}\\setminus\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\)\|=k\. Ifn∈Rn\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}, it reveals the\(k−1\)\(k\-1\)smallest such unused strings and, in addition, the smallest string inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}that has previously been output by𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}but has not yet been revealed by the adversary \(if such a string exists\)\. This exhaustion isf\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\-bounded withf​\(n\)=k\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}f\}\}\(n\)=kand satisfies\|Δ​An\|≤k\|\\Delta\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\|\\leq kby construction\. Moreover, by construction, the adversary outputs all strings inG∩T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, and henceAn↑T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\.

Now consider the firstnninteraction steps\. The generator outputs at mostnnstrings in total\. On each non\-repetition stepn′∉Rn^\{\\prime\}\\notin\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}withn′≤nn^\{\\prime\}\\leq nthe adversary reveals thekksmallest unused strings, so apart from ther​\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(n\)repetition steps, each block ofk\+1k\+1newly used strings can contain at most one generator output\. Consequently, among the first\(k\+1\)​n\(k\+1\)nstrings inT\(k\+1\)​n\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{\(k\+1\)n\}, the generator can cover at mostn\+r​\(n\)n\+\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(n\)of them:

\|G∩T\(k\+1\)​n\|≤n\+r​\(n\)\.\\bigl\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{\(k\+1\)n\}\\bigr\|\\leq n\+\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(n\)\.\(126\)Divide by\(k\+1\)​n\(k\+1\)nand takelim infn→∞\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\. Sincer​\(n\)=𝒪​\(log⁡n\)r\(n\)=\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(\\log n\)for powers of two, we haver​\(n\)/n→0\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(n\)/n\\to 0, and thus

lim infn→∞\|G∩Tn\|\|Tn\|≤1k\+1,\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\leq\\frac\{1\}\{k\+1\},\(127\)which is exactly[Eq\.˜125](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A7.E125)\.

#### Partial exhaustion\.

Now letA⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}be arbitrary, and let the adversary reveal only strings fromA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}using the same strategy as above, with smallest string interpreted with respect to the order induced by𝑻\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}restricted toA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\. Consider a collection𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}that contains bothA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}andT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Crucially, the revealed exhaustion is compatible with either choice of true language in\{A,T\}\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\\}\. Since the generator’s behavior depends only on the revealed history, it produces the same output stream in both cases\. Therefore, because the generator must eventually reach tail precision11when the true language isA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, it can output only finitely many strings outsideA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\. Hence,\|G∩\(Tn∖A\)\|=𝒪​\(1\)\.\\bigl\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\\bigr\|=\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(1\)\.We apply the same counting argument as in the full case:

\|G∩Tn\|=\|G∩\(A∩Tn\)\|\+𝒪​\(1\)≤\|A∩Tn\|k\+1\+𝒪​\(log⁡\|A∩Tn\|\)\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|=\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\)\|\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(1\)\\leq\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{k\+1\}\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(\\log\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\)\(128\)Dividing by\|Tn\|\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|and takinglim infn→∞\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}, the second term vanishes and thus

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=lim infn→∞\|G∩Tn\|\|Tn\|≤1k\+1​lim infn→∞\|A∩Tn\|\|Tn\|=1k\+1​ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\leq\\frac\{1\}\{k\+1\}\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\\frac\{1\}\{k\+1\}\\,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\.\(129\)∎

## Appendix HGeneration with novelty

### H\.1Generation with novelty but without perfect tail precision

See[4\.8](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem8)

###### Proof\.

Fix an arbitrary enumeration𝑬=\{En\}n=1∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{E\}\}=\\\{E\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=1\}^\{\\infty\}ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\. Choose an exploration setR⊂ℕ\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\subset\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}according to[Definition˜4\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem1)and letr​\(m\)=def\|R∩\{1,…,m\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\)\\mathrel\{\\stackrel\{\{\\scriptstyle\\textnormal\{\\tiny def\}\}\}\{\{=\}\}\}\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\cap\\\{1,\\dots,m\\\}\|\. We will schedule exploration rounds on eachr∈R\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\. We construct𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}iteratively as described in[Algorithm˜6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg6)\. By construction,Gn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}increases by11in each round, as the outputs are novel\. Moreover, exploration happens only whenever the current timestep reaches the next value inR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\. This will ensure that forGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}with\|Gn\|=n\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=n, the number of exploratory strings is at mostr​\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(n\)\. We first prove the recall bound\.

#### The1−ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)1\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}bound\.

We show that Algorithm[6](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg6)generates every string inT∖A\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\. Fix any𝒙∈T∖A\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, and letllbe such thatΔ​El=\{𝒙\}\\Delta E\_\{l\}=\\\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\\}\. Since𝒙∉A\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\notin\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, the adversary never outputs𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}, so𝒙∉Am\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}\\notin\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}at all timesmm\. On exploration rounds, the algorithm outputs the firstΔ​Ej\\Delta E\_\{j\}not inGm−1∪Am\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}and advancesjj\. Exploration rounds occur infinitely often and𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}cannot be made unavailable byA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, as it does not occur in anyAm\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\. Hence,𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}is either produced in a safe round or, if not, the pointerjjreacheslleventually, and the algorithm outputs𝒙\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{x\}\}\}in an exploration round\. ThusG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}containsT∖A\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\.

Applying Lemma[4\.7](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem7)yields

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥1−ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\ \\geq\\ 1\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\.\(130\)

#### Theρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)3\\frac\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\}\{3\}bound\.

Consider only the safe rounds \(those withm∉Rm\\notin\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\)\. SinceR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}has no consecutive integers, between two consecutive safe rounds, there is at most one exploration round\. Hence, between running the safe procedure with intersection and pods updates, at most two adversary strings are buffered\. Therefore, the safe subroutine is executed in a22\-batched regime\. Although exploration outputs may change the future composition of the pods, the charging argument from[Lemma˜4\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem5)still applies directly to the interleaved routine\. Between two consecutive safe rounds, the adversary reveals at most two new strings\. Moreover, whenever an exploration round makes a string unavailable to the safe routine, that string already belongs toG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}and therefore cannot create an additional missed string inA∖\(𝒫∪G\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\setminus\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\. Any pod element that is neither revealed by the adversary nor generated during exploration remains available and is eventually output by a safe round\. Hence, the charging bounds of[Lemma˜4\.5](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem5)hold withk=2k=2for the generated languageG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}, yielding

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)3\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq\\frac\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\}\{3\}\.\(131\)
Combining both bounds gives

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥max⁡\(1−ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\),ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)3\)\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq\\ \\max\\Big\(1\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}^\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\},\\frac\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\}\{3\}\\Big\)\.\(132\)Note that we cannot simply add up the bounds\. This is because[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)’s \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\) routine guarantees generation fromT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, not fromA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, and might hence generate solely fromT∖A\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\.

#### Precision\.

As all outputs are novel,\|Gn\|=n\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=n\. For eachGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}, the number of outputs from explorations \(and hence possible hallucinations\) is at mostr​\(n\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(n\); furthermore,[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)’s \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\) algorithm guarantees stabilization of tail precision to11in finite time, meaning that all outputs from safe rounds except finitely many lie inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Hence

\|Gn∩T\|≥n−r​\(n\)−𝒪​\(1\)\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\\geq n\-\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(n\)\-\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(1\)\(133\)and therefore

π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)\\displaystyle\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=lim infn→∞\|Gn∩T\|\|Gn\|\\displaystyle=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\(134\)≥lim infn→∞\(1−r​\(n\)\+𝒪​\(1\)n\)\\displaystyle\\geq\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\left\(1\-\\frac\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(n\)\+\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{O\}\}\}\(1\)\}\{n\}\\right\)\(135\)=1\.\\displaystyle=1\.\(136\)
∎

Algorithm 6Language generation in the limit with novelty and without perfect tail precision\.UpdateChaintakes the adversary’s input and a sequence of languages and returns an updated sequence of languages and a chain of intersections of consistent languages;IdIntersecttakes the timestep and a level index, two intersection chains and an identified intersection and returns the next level index and the next identified intersection;AggrSettakes two identified intersections and two intersection chains and returns an aggressive set, i\.e\., a superset of the current identified intersection\.Input:adversarial exhaustion\{An\}n=0∞\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, enumeration𝑬\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{E\}\}ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}, infinite exploration setR⊂ℕ\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\subset\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}, pod size sequence\(sn\)n≥1\(s\_\{n\}\)\_\{n\\geq 1\}, ordered sequence\(Si′\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}of languages in𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}Ensures:Increasing exhaustion𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}\.1:

G0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

n←1n\\leftarrow 1,

j←1j\\leftarrow 1,

U0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset\{unavailable strings\},

𝒫0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset\{pod pool\},

\(Si\(0\)\)i≥1←\(Si′\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(0\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\\leftarrow\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\{consistent languages\},

k0←1k\_\{0\}\\leftarrow 1,

Aprev←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{\\text\{prev\}\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

ℐ\(0\)←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(0\)\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

C0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset
2:

rnext←min⁡\(R\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}\\leftarrow\\min\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\)
3:for

m=1,2,3,…m=1,2,3,\\dotsdo

4:Observe

Am\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}
5:if

m≠rnextm\\neq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}then

6:

\(\(Si\(n\)\)i≥1,Cn\)←\\bigl\(\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\\bigr\)\\leftarrowUpdateChain​\(Am∖Aprev,\(Si\(n−1\)\)i≥1\)\\textsc\{UpdateChain\}\\bigl\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{\\text\{prev\}\},\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\\bigr\)
7:

\(ℐ\(n\),kn\)←\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\},k\_\{n\}\)\\leftarrowIdIntersect\(n,kn−1,ℐ\(n−1\),Cn−1,Cn\)\(n,k\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\)

8:

ℐ~\(n\)←\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\leftarrowAggrSet\(n,ℐ\(n−1\),ℐ\(n\),Cn−1,Cn\)\(n,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\)

9:

Un←Un−1∪Am∪Gm−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\.

10:

Pn←\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrowthe

sns\_\{n\}≺\\prec\-smallest elements of

ℐ~\(n\)∖Un\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}
11:

Un←Un∪Pn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}
12:

𝒫n←𝒫n−1∪Pn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}\.

13:

Gm←Gm−1∪min≺⁡\(𝒫n∖\(Am∪Gm−1\)\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\\cup\\min\_\{\\prec\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\)\)
14:

Un←Un∪Gm\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\}
15:

Aprev←Am\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{\\text\{prev\}\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}
16:

n←n\+1n\\leftarrow n\+1⊳\\trianglerightsafe rounds

17:else

18:while

Ej⊆Am∪Gm−1E\_\{j\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}do

19:

j←j\+1j\\leftarrow j\+1
20:endwhile

21:

Gm←Gm−1∪Δ​Ej\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\\cup\\Delta E\_\{j\}
22:

j←j\+1j\\leftarrow j\+1
23:

rnext←min⁡\(\{r∈R:r\>rnext\}\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}\\leftarrow\\min\(\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\colon\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\>\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}\\\}\)⊳\\trianglerightexploration

24:endif

25:endfor

## Appendix IGeneration withγ\\gamma\-novelty

###### Lemma I\.1\.

There exists aγ\\gamma\-admissible exploration set \([Definition˜4\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem2)\) for everyγ<1\\gamma<1\.

###### Proof\.

LetM≥max⁡\{2,⌈1/\(1−γ\)⌉\}M\\geq\\max\\\{2,\\lceil 1/\(1\-\\gamma\)\\rceil\\\}and setR=\{M​2i:i∈ℕ0\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}=\\\{M2^\{i\}:i\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\_\{0\}\\\}\. ThenR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}is infinite, has no consecutive elements and satisfiesr​\(m\)/m→0\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\)/m\\to 0\. Furthermore,

r​\(m\)≤mM≤\(1−γ\)​m\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(m\)\\leq\\frac\{m\}\{M\}\\leq\(1\-\\gamma\)m\.\(137\)∎

### I\.1Generation withγ\\gamma\-novelty without perfect tail precision

See[4\.9](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem9)

###### Proof\.

[Algorithm˜7](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg7)combines safe rounds with exploration rounds scheduled according to aγ\\gamma\-admissible exploration set\. Since exploration rounds are not consecutive and the safe routine is not advanced during exploration rounds, the safe routine sees a22\-batched adversary\. The exploration rounds output elements from an enumeration𝑬\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{E\}\}ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\. In those rounds, we allow the generator to output strings that have been previously revealed by the adversary while it skips strings that already belong toGn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\. Thus,\|Gn\|=n\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=n\. An exploration round either does not influence the safe rounds by outputting a string that the safe rounds would never produce or makes the safe routine advance more quickly\. The proof of precision is analogous to[Theorem˜4\.8](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem8)\. It remains to show thatγ\\gamma\-novelty is satisfied and that the recall is11\.

#### γ\\gamma\-novelty\.

The algorithm chooses aγ\\gamma\-admissible exploration setR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\. All safe rounds produce novel outputs, i\.e\., outputs that are chosen outsideAn∪Gn−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\. Therefore, non\-novel outputs can occur only on exploration rounds\. LetNnN\_\{n\}be the cumulative novel set from[Definition˜3\.7](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem7)\. For every timestepnn, by[Definition˜4\.2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S4.Thmtheorem2)

\|Gn∖Nn\|≤r​\(n\)≤\(1−γ\)​n\.\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\setminus N\_\{n\}\|\\leq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\(n\)\\leq\(1\-\\gamma\)n\.\(138\)
Combined with\|Gn\|=n\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|=n, it follows that

\|Nn\|\|Gn\|=1−\|Gn∖Nn\|\|Gn\|≥γ\.\\frac\{\|N\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=1\-\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\setminus N\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\geq\\gamma\.\(139\)Thus, the generator isγ\\gamma\-novel\.

#### Recall\.

Let𝑬=\{Ej\}j=1∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{E\}\}=\\\{E\_\{j\}\\\}\_\{j=1\}^\{\\infty\}be the fixed enumeration ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\. In each exploration round, the algorithm outputs the first elementΔ​Ej\\Delta E\_\{j\}such thatΔ​Ej⊈Gn−1\\Delta E\_\{j\}\\nsubseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}\. SinceR\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}is infinite, this exploration routine is invoked infinitely many times\. We show that every element ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}is eventually generated\. Fixm∈ℕm\\in\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}\. Form=1m=1, eitherΔ​E1\\Delta E\_\{1\}is output in the first exploration round, or it has already been generated by a safe round\. In either case,Δ​E1∈G\\Delta E\_\{1\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\.

Now assume that, for somem\>1m\>1, all elements inEm⋆E\_\{m^\{\\star\}\}for everym⋆<mm^\{\\star\}<mhave already been added toG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. Consider the next exploration round\. When the exploration routine scans the enumeration𝑬\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{E\}\}, it skips allEm⋆E\_\{m^\{\\star\}\}withm⋆<mm^\{\\star\}<m, since they already belong to the current guessed language\. Hence, the routine reachesEmE\_\{m\}\. IfΔ​Em⊈Gn−1\\Delta E\_\{m\}\\nsubseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}, it is output in this exploration round\. If it is not output in this exploration round, then this can only be becauseΔ​Em\\Delta E\_\{m\}has been output in a previous safe round and thusΔ​Em⊆Gn−1\\Delta E\_\{m\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\-1\}already\. In either case,Δ​Em⊆G\\Delta E\_\{m\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\.

By induction, every element ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}is eventually contained inG\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}, and thereforeΣ∗⊆G\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. SinceT⊆Σ∗\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\subseteq\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}, it follows thatT⊆G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\. Therefore,

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=lim infn→∞\|G∩Tn\|\|Tn\|=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}=1\.\(140\)
∎

Algorithm 7Language generation in the limit withγ\\gamma\-novelty and without perfect tail precision\.UpdateChaintakes the adversary’s input and a sequence of languages and returns an updated sequence of languages and a chain of intersections of consistent languages;IdIntersecttakes the timestep and a level index, two intersection chains and an identified intersection and returns the next level index and the next identified intersection;AggrSettakes two identified intersections and two intersection chains and returns an aggressive set, i\.e\., a superset of the current identified intersection\.Input:adversarial exhaustion\{An\}n=0∞\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, enumeration𝑬\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{E\}\}ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}, infiniteγ\\gamma\-admissible exploration setR⊂ℕ\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\subset\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathbb\{N\}\}\}, pod size sequence\(sn\)n≥1\(s\_\{n\}\)\_\{n\\geq 1\}, ordered sequence\(Si′\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}of languages in𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}Ensures:Increasing exhaustion𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}\.1:

G0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

n←1n\\leftarrow 1,

j←1j\\leftarrow 1,

U0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset\{unavailable strings\},

𝒫0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset\{pod pool\},

\(Si\(0\)\)i≥1←\(Si′\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(0\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\\leftarrow\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\{consistent languages\},

k0←1k\_\{0\}\\leftarrow 1,

Aprev←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{\\text\{prev\}\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

ℐ\(0\)←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(0\)\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

C0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset
2:

rnext←min⁡\(R\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}\\leftarrow\\min\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\)
3:for

m=1,2,3,…m=1,2,3,\\dotsdo

4:Observe

Am\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}
5:if

m≠rnextm\\neq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}then

6:

\(\(Si\(n\)\)i≥1,Cn\)←\\bigl\(\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\\bigr\)\\leftarrowUpdateChain​\(Am∖Aprev,\(Si\(n−1\)\)i≥1\)\\textsc\{UpdateChain\}\\bigl\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{\\text\{prev\}\},\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\\bigr\)
7:

\(ℐ\(n\),kn\)←\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\},k\_\{n\}\)\\leftarrowIdIntersect\(n,kn−1,ℐ\(n−1\),Cn−1,Cn\)\(n,k\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\)

8:

ℐ~\(n\)←\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\leftarrowAggrSet\(n,ℐ\(n−1\),ℐ\(n\),Cn−1,Cn\)\(n,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\)

9:

Un←Un−1∪Am∪Gm−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\.

10:

Pn←\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrowthe

sns\_\{n\}≺\\prec\-smallest elements of

ℐ~\(n\)∖Un\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}
11:

Un←Un∪Pn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}
12:

𝒫n←𝒫n−1∪Pn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}\.

13:

Gm←Gm−1∪min≺⁡\(𝒫n∖\(Am∪Gm−1\)\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\\cup\\min\_\{\\prec\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\)\)
14:

Un←Un∪Gm\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\}
15:

Aprev←Am\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{\\text\{prev\}\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}
16:

n←n\+1n\\leftarrow n\+1⊳\\trianglerightsafe rounds

17:else

18:while

Ej⊆Gm−1E\_\{j\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}do

19:

j←j\+1j\\leftarrow j\+1
20:endwhile

21:

Gm←Gm−1∪Δ​Ej\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\\cup\\Delta E\_\{j\}
22:

j←j\+1j\\leftarrow j\+1
23:

rnext←min⁡\(\{r∈R:r\>rnext\}\)\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}\\leftarrow\\min\(\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}R\}\\colon\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\>\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}r\}\_\{\\text\{next\}\}\\\}\)⊳\\trianglerightexploration

24:endif

25:endfor

###### Corollary I\.2\.

Fix anyγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\)\. For anyT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}and any single\-step full adversarial exhaustion𝐀\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}withAn↑T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},[Algorithm˜7](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg7)generates aγ\\gamma\-novel exhaustion𝐆=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withGn↑G\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}such that

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=1,π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=1,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\.\(141\)

### I\.2Generation withγ\\gamma\-novelty and with perfect tail precision

We considerγ\\gamma\-novel generation under the requirement of perfect tail precision\. In contrast to the strict novelty setting withγ=1\\gamma=1, aγ\\gamma\-novel generator forγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\)may use a controlled fraction of non\-novel outputs\. We use these non\-novel outputs to repeat all the strings revealed by the adversary\. In[Algorithm˜8](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg8), we interleave safe rounds with repetition rounds\.

Algorithm 8Language generation in the limit withγ\\gamma\-novelty and perfect tail precision\.UpdateChaintakes the adversary’s input and a sequence of languages and returns an updated sequence of languages and a chain of intersections of consistent languages;IdIntersecttakes the timestep and a level index, two intersection chains and an identified intersection and returns the next level index and the next identified intersection;AggrSettakes two identified intersections and two intersection chains and returns an aggressive set, i\.e\., a superset of the current identified intersection\.Input:adversarial exhaustion\{An\}n=0∞\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, novelty parameterγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\), pod size sequence\(sn\)n≥1\(s\_\{n\}\)\_\{n\\geq 1\}, ordered sequence\(Si′\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}of languages in𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}\.Ensures:increasing exhaustion𝑮=\{Gn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}\.1:

L←⌈11−γ⌉L\\leftarrow\\left\\lceil\\frac\{1\}\{1\-\\gamma\}\\right\\rceil
2:

G0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

n←1n\\leftarrow 1,

U0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset\{unavailable strings\},

𝒫0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset\{pod pool\},

\(Si\(0\)\)i≥1←\(Si′\)i≥1\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(0\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\\leftarrow\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\\prime\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\{consistent languages\},

k0←1k\_\{0\}\\leftarrow 1,

Aprev←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{\\text\{prev\}\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

ℐ\(0\)←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(0\)\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset,

C0←∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{0\}\\leftarrow\\emptyset
3:for

m=1,2,3,…m=1,2,3,\\dotsdo

4:Observe

Am\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}
5:if

m≡0\(modL\)m\\equiv 0\\pmod\{L\}Am∖Gm−1≠∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\\neq\\emptysetthen

6:

Gm←Gm−1∪\{min≺⁡\(Am∖Gm−1\)\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\\cup\\\{\\min\_\{\\prec\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\)\\\}⊳\\trianglerightrepetition round

7:else

8:

\(\(Si\(n\)\)i≥1,Cn\)←\\bigl\(\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\\bigr\)\\leftarrowUpdateChain​\(Am∖Aprev,\(Si\(n−1\)\)i≥1\)\\textsc\{UpdateChain\}\\bigl\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{\\text\{prev\}\},\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}S\}^\{\(n\-1\)\}\_\{i\}\)\_\{i\\geq 1\}\\bigr\)
9:

\(ℐ\(n\),kn\)←\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\},k\_\{n\}\)\\leftarrowIdIntersect\(n,kn−1,ℐ\(n−1\),Cn−1,Cn\)\(n,k\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\)

10:

ℐ~\(n\)←\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\leftarrowAggrSet\(n,ℐ\(n−1\),ℐ\(n\),Cn−1,Cn\)\(n,\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\-1\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}^\{\(n\)\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\-1\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}C\}\_\{n\}\)

11:

Un←Un−1∪Am∪Gm−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}
12:

Pn←\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrowthe

sns\_\{n\}≺\\prec\-smallest elements of

ℐ~\(n\)∖Un\\widetilde\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{I\}\}\}^\{\(n\)\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}
13:

Un←Un∪Pn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}
14:

𝒫n←𝒫n−1∪Pn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\-1\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}P\}\_\{n\}
15:

Gm←Gm−1∪\{min≺⁡\(𝒫n∖\(Am∪Gm−1\)\)\}\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\\cup\\\{\\min\_\{\\prec\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{P\}\}\_\{n\}\\setminus\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\)\)\\\}
16:

Un←Un∪Gm\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}U\}\_\{n\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\}
17:

Aprev←Am\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{\\text\{prev\}\}\\leftarrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}
18:

n←n\+1n\\leftarrow n\+1⊳\\trianglerightsafe round

19:endif

20:endfor

###### Theorem I\.3\.

Let𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be a countable collection of languages and letT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be the target language\. Letγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\)be the required fraction of novel strings\. Fix an enumeration𝐓=\{Tn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. There exists aγ\\gamma\-novel generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}such that, for any single\-step adversarial exhaustion𝐀=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑A⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}andρ^∗​\(𝐓,A\)≥α\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\\geq\\alpha, the generated single\-step exhaustion𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}satisfies:

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)≥α,π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1,τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}\\geq\\alpha,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\.\(142\)Moreover, the recall guarantee is tight in an adversarial sense\.

###### Proof\.

The caseγ=0\\gamma=0is covered in[Theorem˜E\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A5.Thmtheorem1)\. Now letγ∈\(0,1\)\\gamma\\in\(0,1\)and letL:=⌈11−γ⌉L:=\\left\\lceil\\frac\{1\}\{1\-\\gamma\}\\right\\rceil\. We divide time into blocks of lengthLLand run[Algorithm˜8](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg8)\. In each block, we run safe rounds using the pods algorithm by[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\(see[Algorithm˜2](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#alg2)\) forL−1L\-1rounds and take one repetition round at the end of the block\. The subroutine for the pods algorithm is updated only on safe rounds, using all adversarial strings revealed since the previous safe round\. Since there is at most one repetition round between two consecutive safe rounds, and the adversary is single\-step bounded, the safe subroutine sees a22\-batched adversary\. On repetition rounds, the generator outputs the smallest adversary\-revealed string that has not yet been generated\. Formally, on a timestepmm, a repetition round outputs the≺\\prec\-smallest element ofAm∖Gm−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}, if this set is nonempty\. IfAm∖Gm−1=∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}=\\emptyset, the generator instead takes a safe round\. The repetition outputs are always valid becauseA⊆T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\\subseteq\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Furthermore, the repetition rounds do not interfere with the22\-batched safe routine in any way, as they never output unused elements from pods that the safe routine might produce later\.

#### γ\\gamma\-novelty\.

The safe rounds output only novel strings: the output is chosen outsideAm∪Gm−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\cup\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}, i\.e\., outside the strings already revealed by the adversary or previously generated\. Only repetition rounds may be non\-novel\. Since there is at most one repetition round in each block of lengthLL, and since the repetition round occurs at the end of the block, everyGm\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\}contains at most one non\-novel output per completed block\. IfAm∖Gm−1=∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}=\\emptyseton a repetition round, the generator takes a safe round instead, which can only increase the fraction of novel outputs\.

LetNnN\_\{n\}denote the cumulative novel set from[Definition˜3\.7](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#S3.Thmtheorem7)\. Consider the setGn∖Nn\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\setminus N\_\{n\}of non\-novel strings generated up to timestepnn\. It holds that

\|Gn∖Nn\|≤⌊\|Gn\|L⌋≤\|Gn\|L\.\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\setminus N\_\{n\}\|\\leq\\left\\lfloor\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{L\}\\right\\rfloor\\leq\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\{L\}\.\(143\)Therefore, we have

\|Nn\|\|Gn\|=1−\|Gn∖Nn\|\|Gn\|≥1−1L≥γ,\\frac\{\|N\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}=1\-\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\\setminus N\_\{n\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\geq 1\-\\frac\{1\}\{L\}\\geq\\gamma,\(144\)where the last inequality follows fromL≥1/\(1−γ\)L\\geq 1/\(1\-\\gamma\)\. Hence the generator isγ\\gamma\-novel\.

#### Tail precision\.

All outputs from repetition rounds belong toA\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}, and therefore toT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. On safe rounds, we run the22\-batched[Kleinberg and Wei](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)’s \([2025b](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#bib.bib8)\) algorithm\. It guarantees stabilization of tail precision to11in finite time, meaning that all outputs from safe rounds except finitely many lie inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Hence, after some finite timestep, every generated string, whether produced by a safe round or by a repetition round, lies inT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. Thus

τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\.\(145\)

#### Precision\.

By[Lemma˜D\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A4.Thmtheorem1), a tail precision of11also implies

π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\.\(146\)

#### Recall\.

We show that every string revealed by the adversary is eventually generated\. Let𝒚∈A\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\. There exists a finite timestepm⋆m^\{\\star\}such that𝒚∈Am\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}for allm≥m⋆m\\geq m^\{\\star\}\. From that time onward, unless𝒚\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}has already been generated by a safe round, it remains inAm∖Gm−1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\. The repetition rounds continue to occur as long asAm∖Gm−1≠∅\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{m\}\\setminus\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\_\{m\-1\}\\neq\\emptyset\. Moreover, since≺\\precis induced by an enumeration ofΣ∗\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\Sigma\}\}^\{\*\}\}\}, each string has only finitely many≺\\prec\-predecessors\. Hence, there are only finitely many elements that can be output in repetition rounds before outputting𝒚\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}, meaning that𝒚\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}is generated eventually\. Hence, every𝒚∈A\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{y\}\}\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}is output eventually, which yields

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=lim infn→∞\|Tn∩G\|\|Tn\|≥lim infn→∞\|Tn∩A\|\|Tn\|=ρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)≥α\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}\\geq\\liminf\_\{n\\to\\infty\}\\frac\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\cap\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\|\}\{\|\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\|\}=\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}\\geq\\alpha\.\(147\)The tightness of the recall bound in an adversarial sense follows from the same argument as in[Theorem˜E\.1](https://arxiv.org/html/2606.28354#A5.Thmtheorem1)\. ∎

The following corollary describes the special case of a full exhaustion𝑨=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, meaningρ^∗​\(𝑻,A\)=1\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\)\}=1\.

###### Corollary I\.4\.

Let𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be a countable collection of languages and letT∈𝒯\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\\in\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{T\}\}\}\}\}be the target language\. Letγ∈\[0,1\)\\gamma\\in\[0,1\)be the required fraction of novel strings\. Fix an enumeration𝐓=\{Tn\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}ofT\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\. There exists aγ\\gamma\-novel generator𝒢\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\{\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\mathcal\{G\}\}\}\}\}such that, for every single\-step full adversarial exhaustion𝐀=\{An\}n=0∞\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\}\}=\\\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\\}\_\{n=0\}^\{\\infty\}withAn↑T\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}A\}\_\{n\}\\uparrow\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}, the generated single\-step exhaustion𝐆\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}satisfies:

ρ^∗​\(𝑻,G\)=1,π^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1,τ^∗​\(T,𝑮\)=1\.\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\rho\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\}\}\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\)\}=1,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\pi\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1,\\qquad\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\widehat\{\\tau\}\_\{\\ast\}\(\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}T\},\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}\\boldsymbol\{\{\\color\[rgb\]\{0,0,0\}\\definecolor\[named\]\{pgfstrokecolor\}\{rgb\}\{0,0,0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@stroke\{0\}\\pgfsys@color@gray@fill\{0\}G\}\}\}\)\}=1\.\(148\)