Week 1: Claude's $1,000 paper portfolio is at $995.66, 0.8 points behind the S&P 500

Reddit r/singularity News

Summary

Week 1 of Anthropic's experiment shows Claude's $1,000 paper portfolio of S&P 500 stocks at $995.66, trailing a buy-and-hold SPY position by 0.80 percentage points after cautious opening buys in XOM, MSFT, GOOGL, TMO and NFLX.

Week 1 · Sep 29 – Oct 2 (4 trading days) Agent Value Week 1 Claude $995.66 −0.43% SPY buy & hold $1,003.66 +0.37% Claude vs the S&P 500: −0.80 percentage points Images, one per day: Day 1 ($1,000.79, +0.42 pp vs SPY): Claude opened four positions on a down day for the market and kept 56% in cash. Day 2 ($1,001.35, +0.68 pp): it added Microsoft. This was its best day relative to the S&P. Day 3 ($993.49, −0.28 pp): Netflix and Thermo Fisher fell and the lead was gone. No trades. Day 4 ($995.66, −0.80 pp): the portfolio was up 0.22% but the S&P rose more. No trades. Week 1: cautious in a nervous market Claude started in a jittery market: the 10-year Treasury yield was at 5.23% (its highest since 2007), oil was above $100, and traders saw a real chance of a Fed hike in October. It invested $540 in five stocks over the first two days and kept about 46% in cash. It made no trades on Days 3 and 4. The five buys Stock Bought Why Since bought XOM $100 Oil above $100 with the Strait of Hormuz shut; a hedge against the tech-heavy rest +2.4% MSFT $100 Azure growing 43%, Copilot past 30M paid seats, two analyst upgrades +1.3% GOOGL $120 About 15% off its high on AI-spending worries; bought the dip +0.5% TMO $120 Raised guidance, best organic growth since 2021; a steady compounder −3.2% NFLX $100 Down 44% from its high, at about 18x 2027 earnings after an upgrade −4.7% Three of the five are up. Thermo Fisher and Netflix are down enough to leave the portfolio behind the S&P for the week. What Claude passed on Fair Isaac: it skipped the stock after a 26% drop on a regulatory change. Micron: it waited until after earnings. Micron beat, and the stock went nowhere. Accenture: the stock jumped about 16% on record bookings. Claude said: "I'm not chasing a one-day spike." Next week Cash: nearly half the portfolio is cash. Will Claude start investing it, or keep waiting while yields are this high? The Fed: whether it hikes in October, and what that does to yields. Oil and Iran: a peace deal would hurt the Exxon trade quickly, and Claude said so when it bought. Netflix: whether Claude sticks with its worst position. How it works: Claude manages a $1,000 paper portfolio of S&P 500 stocks for 365 trading days, against $1,000 of SPY bought and held. Each morning before the open, it researches the news and places orders, which fill at the opening price. Rules: at most 5 trades a day and at most 30% in one stock; no ETFs, leverage or shorting. Every decision is logged in the repo with its reasoning. Paper trading experiment. No real money. Not financial advice.
Original Article

Similar Articles

Anthropic's march to profitability (3 minute read)

TLDR AI

Anthropic projects $10.9 billion in Q2 revenue and its first profitable quarter, driven by enterprise adoption of Claude's coding tools, as the company prepares for an expected IPO in October.