Canadian legislator reads out apparent LLM response in floor speech
Summary
A Canadian legislator inadvertently read aloud an instruction from an LLM (like 'here's a more natural version') during a legislative speech, sparking criticism and media attention.
<p>Anyone who has used the Internet in recent years is probably used to encountering <a href="https://arstechnica.com/ai/2024/01/lazy-use-of-ai-leads-to-amazon-products-called-i-cannot-fulfill-that-request/">telltale signs of LLM prompting</a> that lazy users sometimes forget to remove from their AI-generated pabulum. But a Canadian legislator took that idea to an embarrassing new level this week, reading an apparent LLM prompt instruction into the record during a floor speech.</p>
<p>Bill Oliver, a Progressive Conservative Party member of the legislative assembly of New Brunswick, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlYa8NV5k-U">noted in a speech last month</a> that "One of the dangers associated with creating advocacy offices is that citizens often develop expectations that exceed the powers actually granted to those offices." He then went on to say out loud that "here’s a more natural, flowing version of that section that reads like a legislative speech rather than a series of short points," a line with all the hallmarks of an LLM presenting an alternative style option in response to a prompt.</p>
<div class="ars-video ars-video--horizontal"><div><div class="relative" allow="fullscreen" loading="lazy" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/wlYa8NV5k-U?start=0&wmode=transparent"></div></div></div>
<p>The odd reading went more or less unnoticed at the time, but video of the remarks started spreading around social media networks <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/newbrunswickcanada/comments/1v2e4fv/pc_mla_bill_oliver_reading_an_ai_prompt_in_the/">like Reddit</a> and <a href="https://www.threads.com/@mikesbloggity/post/DbGJx1kiQ11/video-pc-mla-bill-oliver-accidentally-reads-ai-instructions-aloud-in-new-brunswick">Threads</a> earlier this week. In Canada, the snafu is now getting mainstream attention <a href="https://www.cbc.ca/player/play/video/9.7281365">from the likes of the <span id="_WtZjap_8JeGj0PEPxOeMKQ_48" class="K6pdKd wtBS9">Canadian Broadcasting Corporation</span></a> and <a href="https://www.thestar.com/opinion/star-columnists/if-politicians-cant-get-the-job-done-without-chatgpt-maybe-they-shouldnt-have-the-job/article_ae1c5ff2-fc93-4f8e-8401-ab47a1e0b279.html">The Toronto Star</a>, the latter of which called it a sign of "a growing divide in our society: between the elites, who are only too happy to delegate their duties to the Borg; and the masses, who find this objectionable."</p><p><a href="https://arstechnica.com/ai/2026/07/canadian-legislator-reads-out-apparent-llm-response-in-floor-speech/">Read full article</a></p>
<p><a href="https://arstechnica.com/ai/2026/07/canadian-legislator-reads-out-apparent-llm-response-in-floor-speech/#comments">Comments</a></p>
View Cached Full Text
Cached at: 07/24/26, 11:05 PM
# Canadian legislator reads out apparent LLM response in floor speech
Source: [https://arstechnica.com/ai/2026/07/canadian-legislator-reads-out-apparent-llm-response-in-floor-speech/](https://arstechnica.com/ai/2026/07/canadian-legislator-reads-out-apparent-llm-response-in-floor-speech/)
Anyone who has used the Internet in recent years is probably used to encountering[telltale signs of LLM prompting](https://arstechnica.com/ai/2024/01/lazy-use-of-ai-leads-to-amazon-products-called-i-cannot-fulfill-that-request/)that lazy users sometimes forget to remove from their AI\-generated pabulum\. But a Canadian legislator took that idea to an embarrassing new level this week, reading an apparent LLM prompt instruction into the record during a floor speech\.
Bill Oliver, a Progressive Conservative Party member of the legislative assembly of New Brunswick,[noted in a speech last month](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlYa8NV5k-U)that “One of the dangers associated with creating advocacy offices is that citizens often develop expectations that exceed the powers actually granted to those offices\.” He then went on to say out loud that “here’s a more natural, flowing version of that section that reads like a legislative speech rather than a series of short points,” a line with all the hallmarks of an LLM presenting an alternative style option in response to a prompt\.
The odd reading went more or less unnoticed at the time, but video of the remarks started spreading around social media networks[like Reddit](https://www.reddit.com/r/newbrunswickcanada/comments/1v2e4fv/pc_mla_bill_oliver_reading_an_ai_prompt_in_the/)and[Threads](https://www.threads.com/@mikesbloggity/post/DbGJx1kiQ11/video-pc-mla-bill-oliver-accidentally-reads-ai-instructions-aloud-in-new-brunswick)earlier this week\. In Canada, the snafu is now getting mainstream attention[from the likes of theCanadian Broadcasting Corporation](https://www.cbc.ca/player/play/video/9.7281365)and[The Toronto Star](https://www.thestar.com/opinion/star-columnists/if-politicians-cant-get-the-job-done-without-chatgpt-maybe-they-shouldnt-have-the-job/article_ae1c5ff2-fc93-4f8e-8401-ab47a1e0b279.html), the latter of which called it a sign of “a growing divide in our society: between the elites, who are only too happy to delegate their duties to the Borg; and the masses, who find this objectionable\.”
Similar Articles
"This is written by an LLM" comments should be flagged as off-topic
The article proposes that comments on Lobsters which merely accuse a post of being LLM-generated should be flagged as off-topic to maintain the quality of discussion.
The LLM Critics Are Right. I Use LLMs Anyway
The author agrees with LLM critics about issues like slop and ethics but still uses LLMs, describing the cognitive dissonance observed at a tech conference.
Detecting undisclosed LLM-generated content in parliamentary texts
This paper evaluates the extent of undisclosed LLM-generated content in parliamentary texts from the UK and Sweden by training an interpretable text classifier, finding a steady increase in undisclosed LLM use from 2022 onwards.
Content for Content’s Sake
The author investigates how LLMs are influencing word usage in coding and everyday language, finding that words favored by LLMs show increased frequency in both coding sessions and Google Trends, raising concerns about humans adopting LLM writing styles.
What's the most useful thing an LLM does for you that isn't writing or coding?
A discussion prompt asking for unusual and practical non-writing, non-coding use cases for LLMs that people have actually adopted.