@ninja_maths: If Koji were a human tutor and they taught my kid Geometry/Algebra II the way shown in these two demos, I'd fire them i…

X AI KOLs Timeline Products

Summary

A critique of the AI tutor Koji, highlighting flaws in its math teaching approach, such as allowing students to fumble without guidance and missing key conceptual explanations.

If Koji were a human tutor and they taught my kid Geometry/Algebra II the way shown in these two demos, I'd fire them immediately. Ignore the shiny marketing and focus on what's actually happening in these demos. - Koji allows the student to fumble around without a clue for a while. - Koji, then realizing the kids are confused, introduces some test points (a finite selection of what could be infinitely many), without explaining why any of these are good candidates: they just appear. - Students then proceed to test to see which point satisfies the equation - a Prealgebra standard. - But here's the kicker - the most important concept the student needs to grasp, the reasons why the center of the circle is located at (1,0), is completely missed! Instead, the student just lines the circle up with the test point. But according to Koji, "you got it!" No, you have not. No high-quality human math tutor would ever do this. The second example (plotting the transformed square root) is even worse. Students cannot think with knowledge they do not have! I genuinely don't like criticizing others who are trying to improve education. But since this has gone super-viral with almost nobody pushing back on these blatant issues, I felt I had no choice.
Original Article
View Cached Full Text

Cached at: 05/31/26, 09:20 PM

If Koji were a human tutor and they taught my kid Geometry/Algebra II the way shown in these two demos, I’d fire them immediately. Ignore the shiny marketing and focus on what’s actually happening in these demos. - Koji allows the student to fumble around without a clue for a while. - Koji, then realizing the kids are confused, introduces some test points (a finite selection of what could be infinitely many), without explaining why any of these are good candidates: they just appear. - Students then proceed to test to see which point satisfies the equation - a Prealgebra standard. - But here’s the kicker - the most important concept the student needs to grasp, the reasons why the center of the circle is located at (1,0), is completely missed! Instead, the student just lines the circle up with the test point. But according to Koji, “you got it!” No, you have not. No high-quality human math tutor would ever do this. The second example (plotting the transformed square root) is even worse. Students cannot think with knowledge they do not have! I genuinely don’t like criticizing others who are trying to improve education. But since this has gone super-viral with almost nobody pushing back on these blatant issues, I felt I had no choice.

Sue (@suekhim): AI is making kids dumber.

It should be making them geniuses.

Introducing Koji, the first AI tutor that gets kids to actually think. 👇

Similar Articles

Koji by Brilliant

Product Hunt

Brilliant has launched Koji, a personal AI tutor designed to bring world-class tutoring into every home.

Retrieval-Augmented Tutoring for Algorithm Tracing and Problem-Solving in AI Education

arXiv cs.AI

This paper presents KITE, a Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)-based intelligent tutoring system for algorithmic reasoning and problem-solving in AI education. The system uses intent-aware Socratic response strategies and multimodal RAG to provide course-grounded, pedagogically appropriate feedback, and is evaluated through metrics, expert review, and simulated student interactions.

Building a custom math tutor powered by ChatGPT

OpenAI Blog

Phil Birchenall created a custom GPT powered by ChatGPT to help his 12-year-old daughter Daisy with math struggles by giving the AI tutor the personality of their dog Izzy, resulting in an engaging and effective learning tool.