How much of an AI agent’s execution quality is actually a data problem?

Reddit r/AI_Agents News

Summary

The author reflects on why AI agents that perform well in demos often fail in real workflows, arguing that execution quality may be more tied to data issues (task examples, tool traces, evaluation sets) than to reasoning or planning alone, and notes that they are exploring this problem through the OpenDCAI/DataFlow project.

I’ve been thinking about why some agents look impressive in demos but become unstable in real workflows. A lot of discussion around agents focuses on planning, tool use, memory, orchestration, multi-agent collaboration, or better harnesses. These are obviously important. But I’m starting to wonder whether many execution problems are also deeply tied to data. For example: * The agent’s behavior depends on the quality of task examples it has seen. * Tool use depends on whether there are enough clean execution traces. * Evaluation depends on whether test cases reflect real user workflows. * Memory and retrieval depend on whether domain data is structured and reliable. * Failure recovery depends on whether past failures are captured and reused. So when an agent fails, maybe it’s not always just a reasoning issue or a prompt issue. It may be that the surrounding data loop is weak: poor task data, weak feedback data, noisy tool traces, missing domain context, or evaluation sets that don’t match production use. Curious how others think about this: Do you see agent execution quality as mostly a model/planning/harness problem, or as something tightly coupled with the data pipeline behind it? This is also one of the problems I’m trying to explore while working on OpenDCAI/DataFlow, though I’m still not sure how well this approach will work in real agent workflows.
Original Article

Similar Articles

Most AI agent evals completely ignore execution efficiency

Reddit r/AI_Agents

The author argues that current AI agent evaluations often overlook execution efficiency, focusing only on final outputs while ignoring redundant actions and costly orchestration issues that arise in production.