neurips 2026: ACs and reviewers have disappeared [D]
Summary
Authors of a NeurIPS 2026 submission report that reviewers and ACs went silent after they submitted their rebuttal early via the Rebuttal button, with no notifications triggered for either side, leaving them anxious with only a day left in the discussion period.
Similar Articles
NeurIPS 2026 Reviewer: AI-Generated Rebuttals (and Paper) [D]
A NeurIPS reviewer reports encountering a paper and rebuttals that appear entirely LLM-generated, expressing frustration and seeking advice on how to evaluate such submissions.
NeurIPS reviewers not engaging [D]
A user seeks advice on how to nudge NeurIPS reviewers to engage with rebuttals, suggesting possible penalties for non-engagement.
[ICML 2026] Scores increased and then decreased!! [D]
A researcher discusses their ICML 2026 paper review experience where a reviewer increased their score during rebuttal but then decreased it again, expressing concern about rejection prospects.
NeurIPS 2026: If the rebuttal addresses your concern, please raise your score [D]
An opinion piece urging NeurIPS reviewers to raise scores when rebuttals address their stated concerns, regardless of personal taste, sparking discussion about the review process.