neurips 2026: ACs and reviewers have disappeared [D]

Reddit r/MachineLearning News

Summary

Authors of a NeurIPS 2026 submission report that reviewers and ACs went silent after they submitted their rebuttal early via the Rebuttal button, with no notifications triggered for either side, leaving them anxious with only a day left in the discussion period.

we submitted our rebuttal via the "Rebuttal" button before the author/reviewer/AC discussion period officially opened (Jul 27 AoE). since then, we've gotten complete silence from all four reviewers and the AC several of us are also reviewing this cycle. when the discussion period opened on Jul 27 AoE, we got no email notification for rebuttals on papers we're reviewing, specifically for the papers whose authors had also posted early via the "Rebuttal" button. so it feels like anything submitted before the window opened may simply have never triggered any notification we also tried: (1) meta-comments visible to everyone, (2) reviewer reminders, and (3) sending an email to the PCs given there's about 1 day left in the discussion period, what do we do? we honestly thought we had a shot at an oral or spotlight given our initial scores. this is completely messed up.
Original Article

Similar Articles

NeurIPS reviewers not engaging [D]

Reddit r/MachineLearning

A user seeks advice on how to nudge NeurIPS reviewers to engage with rebuttals, suggesting possible penalties for non-engagement.

AC comment and our reply disappeared on OpenReview [D]

Reddit r/MachineLearning

A user on OpenReview noticed that an Area Chair's comment and their reply have disappeared, raising concerns about potential bias in paper rejection decisions. They are seeking confirmation from others if this is a normal occurrence.

ICLR 2027 is still handing out desk rejects [N]

Reddit r/MachineLearning

ICLR 2027 continues to issue desk rejects for submissions, with the community being thanked for helping guard against low-quality AI-generated papers flooding the review process.