Not every agent action should need the same approval

Reddit r/AI_Agents News

Summary

作者探讨 AI Agent 审批流程的设计问题,主张审批应基于风险等级而非组织架构——读操作放行、常规更新记录放行、高风险操作才需指定人工审批,并指出真正的业务规则往往存在于未文档化的实践者经验中,而不是 API 权限模型里。

I've been thinking about how we do approvals for AI agents, and honestly the whole thing feels backwards. Not every action deserves the same approval. A read-only lookup risks nothing. A routine update risks a little. A consequential action risks a lot. But most approval flows don't see that. They follow the org chart instead of the risk. So everything waits for the same manager. Everything takes the same two days. The low-risk work stalls for no reason, and the high-risk work gets the same rubber stamp as everything else. And here's the part that gets me: the real rules were never written by the platform people. They were written by the practitioners in the trenches, and none of them are in any API contract. Testimonials need a human before they go live. Escalation happens after two contacts. Refunds under fifty dollars are fine when the order is paid and never refunded before. Timeline rules nobody wrote down anywhere. Those aren't edge cases. Those are the approval flow. The risk lives in the unwritten rule, not in the endpoint. And an agent that can't see the rule can't follow it, no matter how clean the permission model looks on paper. So design approvals around the risk. Let the read go through. Let the routine update go through with a log. Make the consequential action wait for a named human, with the reason attached. Genuinely curious: what is the highest-risk action your agent can take today without asking anyone?
Original Article

Similar Articles

Human approval is too vague for production agents

Reddit r/AI_Agents

The article argues that human-in-the-loop in agent systems should move from vague approvals to explicit, auditable step-level signed decision records with detailed evidence, payloads, idempotency keys, rollback paths, and ownership. It highlights the danger of approving a black-box story rather than a specific operation.